[5d5] fresh form — RFC 15 forms consuming fresh-ui seams (PLAN pending) by rickylabs · Pull Request #38 · rickylabs/netscript

rickylabs · 2026-06-12T20:28:05Z

Sub-gate 5/6 of Wave 5d. Scope: ./form (RFC 15; over-cap 577/519/475), consuming the fresh-ui form seams delivered in 5c (form-field, control-props). Browser validation on real routes. PLAN phase opens with the supervisor handover prompt in the 5d umbrella run dir.

🤖 Generated with Claude Code

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

rickylabs · 2026-06-12T22:20:37Z

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code output=pr-comment iterations=800 use harness

Activate SKILL

netscript-harness
netscript-doctrine
jsr-audit
deno-fresh
frontend-design
ux-patterns

RE-DISPATCH — phase 1 of 2: RESEARCH ONLY. The previous run (trace .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27442097563-1/ on this branch) hit the 500-iteration limit and wrote no artifact files — any completion claims in its summary are false, but its distilled findings are real. Read its summary.md first and REUSE those findings instead of re-deriving them.

Authority docs on this branch — read before anything else:

.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/handover-5d5-plan.md — your full handover. Execute ONLY its MEASURE-FIRST + research portion now; design.md/plan.md come in a follow-up trigger after supervisor review of your research.
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/plan.md — BINDING umbrella target architecture.

WRITE-EARLY CONTRACT (non-negotiable):

Within your first ~15 actions, CREATE .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md as a skeleton (headings + TODO markers) and append findings incrementally as you learn. Start drift.md (entries D-5d5-n) the same way.
The workflow auto-commits leftover workspace files when the run ends — whatever you wrote survives even if you hit the budget. An 80%-complete research.md on the branch beats a perfect one that never lands.
Budget discipline: symbol maps from deno doc, export statements, and targeted grep — don't read schema-adapter.ts (16.3K) / types.ts (16K) / field-descriptors.ts (15.5K) end-to-end; stop exploring at ~60% of budget and consolidate.

Scope of THIS run (research only):

MEASURE-FIRST: combined deno doc --lint for ./form; deno check --unstable-kv; private-type-ref count; over-cap inventory (16.3K/16K/15.5K trio across the 26-file cluster).
Symbol map of ./form public surface + the descriptor/adapter/state internal seams (decomposition raw material).
fresh↔fresh-ui seam analysis: read packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, registry/lib/control-props.ts, and packages/fresh-ui/docs/l0-conventions.md; document the exact state the form system must emit (errors, pending, values) and the data-*/ARIA attribute contract fresh-ui expects. This is the marquee integration of the wave — the research must nail the current truth on both sides.
Standard Schema landscape with sources (zod/valibot/arktype interop) as candidate target for schema-adapter.ts; progressive-enhancement market bar (Remix/React Router actions, Next.js server actions + useActionState, TanStack Form) — gaps worth closing vs deferring.

Expected output: research.md + started drift.md committed to this branch; summary via OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH (never post comments yourself) with the MEASURE-FIRST table, seam findings, what was reused from the prior trace, remaining gaps, and final line RESEARCH COMPLETE — READY FOR DESIGN TRIGGER (or explicit blockers).

Hard rules: PLAN-phase research only — zero implementation; no lockfile changes; no deno cache --reload. Root check excludes packages/fresh — always measure entrypoints directly.

Correction: a previous attempt of this run was cancelled by supervisor error ~15 min after start; ignore any run-274456* trace under .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/. The reusable run-1 findings remain the trace named above.

CHAIN (agent-to-agent handoff, non-negotiable): If and ONLY if you finish successfully (research.md committed to this branch), END your summary file (OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH) with the following block verbatim so phase 2 fires automatically when the workflow posts your summary. If you fail or are cut off, end with explicit blockers and NO trigger block.

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code output=pr-comment iterations=800 use harness

PHASE 2 of 2 — DESIGN + PLAN for [5d5 form]. Authority docs on this branch: .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/handover-5d5-plan.md + BINDING umbrella plan.md in the same dir. REUSE the committed phase-1 research at .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md — do not re-derive it. Deliver design.md + plan.md + context-pack.md and update drift.md (entries D-5d5-n), committed to this branch per the handover's expected-output spec; plan.md MUST end with: Review map · Assumptions · Questions for supervisor · Dependencies & merge impact · Side-effect ledger. WRITE-EARLY CONTRACT: create skeleton files within your first ~15 actions, append incrementally, consolidate at ~60% budget. Hard rules: PLAN only — zero implementation; no lockfile changes; no deno cache --reload. On success END your summary with this exact PLAN-EVAL trigger block (on failure: blockers, no trigger):

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max output=pr-comment iterations=400 use harness

PLAN-EVAL (separate evaluator session) for [5d5 form] per .llm/harness/evaluator/plan-protocol.md and .llm/harness/gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md: evaluate research.md/design.md/plan.md in .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/ on this branch against the BINDING umbrella plan. Commit plan-eval.md to that run dir. Your summary MUST end with the verdict line VERDICT: APPROVED or VERDICT: NEEDS-REVISION plus numbered findings. Evaluation only — zero implementation, zero plan edits.

rickylabs · 2026-06-12T22:20:49Z

OpenHands Agent — Agent failed

Model: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: failure
Summary source: synthesized-after-iteration-limit
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27446387806-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27446387806-1

OpenHands Agent Summary — INCOMPLETE (iteration limit)

The agent hit the maximum iterations limit (800) before
finishing the task. Any commits on the branch reflect partial work;
treat claims of completed artifacts as unverified.

Re-trigger with a narrower task or a higher iterations= value.

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27446387806

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T08:26:54Z

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code output=pr-comment iterations=800 use harness

Activate SKILL

netscript-harness
netscript-doctrine
jsr-audit
deno-fresh
frontend-design
ux-patterns

RESEARCH COMPLETION (finish phase 1). A prior run for [5d5 form] hit its iteration budget and committed an incomplete research.md plus real measurement output. This run FINISHES the research — it does not start over. Avoid all unnecessary rework.

Authority docs on this branch (read first): .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/handover-5d5-plan.md (execute only its MEASURE-FIRST + research portion) and the BINDING umbrella plan.md in the same dir.

REUSE (do not redo): Your prior run committed rich measurement artifacts in this run dir — REUSE them instead of re-measuring: deno-doc-lint.txt, doc-lint-form.txt, doc-lint-raw.txt, deno-publish-dry-run.txt / publish-dry-run-form.txt / dry-run-raw.txt, form-doc.json / form-doc-current.json / form-symbols.json. The current research.md is only a checklist — read those artifacts and write the findings into it.

WRITE-EARLY CONTRACT: open .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md immediately and append into the existing skeleton as you go; the workflow auto-commits leftover workspace files even if you run out of budget, so never batch the write to the end. Keep drift.md (D-5d5-n) current. Stop exploring at ~60% of budget and spend the rest consolidating.

FILL: Complete all sections: MEASURE-FIRST table (from the committed artifacts), form/ inventory + the fresh<->fresh-ui seam (fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, registry/lib/control-props.ts, docs/l0-conventions.md) — state + data-*/ARIA contract, Standard Schema landscape (zod/valibot/arktype interop) + progressive-enhancement market bar (Remix/React Router actions, Next.js server actions + useActionState, TanStack Form gaps) with sources, and Drift/risks/gaps (D-5d5-n).

Output: completed research.md + current drift.md committed to THIS branch; summary via OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH (never post PR comments yourself) with the MEASURE-FIRST table, what you reused from the prior artifacts, remaining gaps, and the final line RESEARCH COMPLETE — READY FOR DESIGN TRIGGER (or explicit blockers). Do NOT emit any @openhands-agent trigger block — the supervisor triggers the design phase manually after review.

Hard rules: research only — zero implementation; no lockfile changes; no deno cache --reload.

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T08:27:05Z

OpenHands Agent — Agent failed

Model: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: failure
Summary source: synthesized-after-iteration-limit
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27461621394-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27461621394-1

OpenHands Agent Summary — INCOMPLETE (iteration limit)

The agent hit the maximum iterations limit (800) before
finishing the task. Any commits on the branch reflect partial work;
treat claims of completed artifacts as unverified.

Re-trigger with a narrower task or a higher iterations= value.

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27461621394

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T10:03:52Z

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code output=pr-comment iterations=900 use harness

Activate SKILL

netscript-harness
netscript-doctrine
jsr-audit
deno-fresh
frontend-design
ux-patterns

RESEARCH COMPLETION — PASS 2 (finish phase 1). A prior completion run for [5d5 form] rebuilt the section structure + committed real measurements, then hit its iteration budget before writing the prose — research.md now has the correct headings with explicit TODO: / (Placeholder…) markers in the body. Your ONLY job this run: REPLACE EVERY TODO: and (Placeholder…) marker in .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md with real content. Do NOT restructure the document, do NOT re-run deno doc --lint / deno check / dry-run — trust the committed measurement artifacts and the numbers already in research.md. Avoid all rework; spend the entire budget on synthesis + sourced market research.

Authority docs on this branch (read first if needed): .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/handover-5d5-plan.md (research portion only) and the BINDING umbrella plan.md in the same dir.

FILL: Only 3 markers remain — fill them: section 4 placeholder (the form/ inventory + fresh<->fresh-ui seam: fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, registry/lib/control-props.ts, docs/l0-conventions.md — state + data-*/ARIA contract), section 5 placeholder (Standard Schema landscape: zod/valibot/arktype interop + progressive-enhancement market bar vs Remix/React Router actions, Next.js server actions + useActionState, TanStack Form gaps — WITH SOURCES), and D-5d5-1 in section 6 (real drift/risk entry, not 'TODO').

WRITE-EARLY CONTRACT: edit research.md in place and save after EACH marker you fill — never batch to the end; the workflow auto-commits leftover workspace files even on budget cutoff. Keep drift.md (D-5d5-n) current.

Output: research.md with ZERO remaining TODO:/(Placeholder…) markers + current drift.md, committed to THIS branch; summary via OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH (never post PR comments yourself) listing the markers filled, sources cited, and the final line RESEARCH COMPLETE — READY FOR DESIGN TRIGGER (or explicit remaining blockers). Do NOT emit any @openhands-agent trigger block — the supervisor triggers the design phase manually after review.

Hard rules: research only — zero implementation; no lockfile changes; no deno cache --reload.

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T10:04:02Z

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27463663659-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27463663659-1

OpenHands Run Summary — [5d5] fresh form research completion

Summary

This run completed Phase 1 research for feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form. It filled the three remaining TODO: / (Placeholder…) markers in .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md and updated the drift ledger (drift.md). No implementation, lockfile changes, or deno cache --reload were performed.

Markers filled

Section 4 — fresh ↔ fresh-ui seam analysis
- Inventory of FormField props and control-props.ts narrowing helpers.
- Mapping of L0 conventions (data-part/data-state/ARIA/native-first/motion/copy fidelity) to the fresh descriptor contract.
- Explicit table mapping FieldDescriptor -> fresh-ui props/ARIA/data attributes.
- Four contract gaps to lock in the design phase (ID vs. name wiring, description wiring, data-state naming, pending UX).
Section 5 — Standard Schema landscape & progressive enhancement market bar
- Current Zod-locked adapter surface in schema-adapter.ts and the library-agnostic public contract.
- Standard Schema spec summary and support matrix for Zod ≥3.23, Valibot ≥0.30, ArkType ≥2.0 with primary source URLs.
- Market comparison against Remix/React Router actions, Next.js Server Actions + useActionState, and TanStack Form, including gaps vs. NetScript form.
- Design verdict: make FormSchemaAdapter canonical, add createStandardSchemaAdapter, split schema-adapter.ts into contract/standard/zod/mod files, and define a per-library introspection plugin for constraints/defaults.
- Close-now vs. defer list.
Section 6 / D-5d5-1 — Root workspace exclusion as umbrella-level publish blocker
- Documented deno.json root exclude of packages/fresh/.
- Cited dry-run artifact: 116 excluded-module errors across packages/fresh/, 23 from packages/fresh/form/*.
- Declared this an umbrella/5d6 final-close risk, not resolvable inside 5d5, with owner and proposed close gate.

Sources cited

Repository files: packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/control-props.ts, packages/fresh-ui/docs/l0-conventions.md, packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.ts, packages/fresh/form/types.ts, packages/fresh/form/field-descriptors.ts, deno.json, dry-run-raw.txt.
External docs: Standard Schema spec (https://github.com/standard-schema/standard-schema); Zod Standard Schema (https://zod.dev/?id=standard-schema); Valibot Standard Schema (https://valibot.dev/guides/standard-schema/); ArkType Standard Schema (https://arktype.io/docs/standard-schema); Remix forms (https://remix.run/docs/en/main/guides/forms); React Router form validation (https://reactrouter.com/start/framework/form-validation); Next.js Server Actions (https://nextjs.org/docs/app/building-your-application/data-fetching/server-actions-and-mutations); React useActionState (https://react.dev/reference/react/useActionState); TanStack Form overview (https://tanstack.com/form/latest/docs/overview).

Changes

.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md — filled sections 4, 5, 6; zero remaining TODO:/(Placeholder…) markers.
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/drift.md — replaced D-5d5-1: TODO with real drift entry.

Validation

grep -E "TODO:|\(Placeholder" against research.md returned no matches (exit 1 because pattern absent).
Three incremental commits saved to the branch so workspace state is durable:
- c0be86c research(5d5): fill fresh<->fresh-ui seam analysis
- cc96a26 research(5d5): fill Standard Schema landscape + market bar
- 220abfa research(5d5): fill D-5d5-1 drift / umbrella-level publish blocker

Responses to review comments or issue comments

Not applicable — this was a research completion run; no review comments were addressed.

Remaining risks

D-5d5-1 remains OPEN; root deno.json excludes packages/fresh/, so @netscript/fresh/form cannot be published from the workspace until 5d6/umbrella final close lifts the exclude.
Design decisions in section 4 (ID vs. name wiring, data-state naming, pending UX) still need to be locked in the Plan & Design phase.
Standard Schema introspection for constraints/defaults is per-library and will require separate adapter files for Valibot/ArkType if pursued beyond Zod.

RESEARCH COMPLETE — READY FOR DESIGN TRIGGER

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27463663659

Sources: packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, control-props.ts, docs/l0-conventions.md; packages/fresh/form/types.ts lines 82-141, 274-297; field-descriptors.ts lines 101-172. Co-Authored-By: openhands <openhands@all-hands.dev>

Sources: schema-adapter.ts, types.ts; Standard Schema spec, Zod/Valibot/ ArkType docs, Remix/React Router/Next.js/TanStack Form docs. Co-Authored-By: openhands <openhands@all-hands.dev>

D-5d5-1: root deno.json excludes packages/fresh/, causing 116 excluded-module dry-run errors; 23 from fresh/form. Cannot be closed inside 5d5; owner is 5d6/umbrella final close. Co-Authored-By: openhands <openhands@all-hands.dev>

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T11:15:45Z

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code output=pr-comment iterations=1000 use harness

Activate SKILL

netscript-harness
netscript-doctrine
jsr-audit
deno-fresh
frontend-design
ux-patterns

PHASE 2 of 2 — DESIGN + PLAN for [5d5 form — RFC 15 forms consuming fresh-ui]. Phase-1 research is COMPLETE and committed on this branch (no open markers) — REUSE it, do not re-derive or re-measure.

Authority docs (read first): .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/handover-5d5-plan.md and the BINDING umbrella plan.md in the same dir.

REUSE: .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/research.md (cite its MEASURE-FIRST numbers) + the committed measurement artifacts in that dir. Do NOT re-run deno doc --lint / deno check / dry-run.

Resolve in design.md the open design decisions the research handed off: the form/ decomposition + the fresh<->fresh-ui seam (form-field.tsx / control-props.ts / l0-conventions.md state + data-*/ARIA contract), the Standard Schema interop choice (zod/valibot/arktype), the progressive-enhancement strategy, and any D-5d5-n drift/risk decisions left open in research.md.

Deliver to .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/: design.md (all required sections per handover "Concept of done (PLAN phase)"), plan.md (PROPOSED slice lock ≤30 — each slice: files touched + gates + the doc-lint/over-cap/private-type-ref budget it retires), context-pack.md, and update drift.md (D-5d5-n). CRITICAL gate rule (learn from sibling 5d4's FAIL): the plan's fitness-gate table must list EVERY gate the archetype requires per .llm/harness/gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md; gates that do not apply must be marked N/A WITH rationale (not silently omitted); each applicable gate must be mapped to the slice(s) that retire it, and slice numbers in the gate table must match the actual commit-slice lock. plan.md MUST end with: Review map · Assumptions · Questions for supervisor · Dependencies & merge impact · Side-effect ledger.

WRITE-EARLY: create skeleton design.md + plan.md within your first ~15 actions and append; the workflow auto-commits leftover files on cutoff. Stop exploring at ~55% budget; spend the rest writing the slice lock + gate map.

Output: artifacts committed to THIS branch; summary via OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH with artifact paths + commit hashes, MEASURE-FIRST table, slice count, gate-to-slice map, top decisions/risks, final line READY FOR PLAN-EVAL. Do NOT emit any @openhands-agent block — the supervisor triggers PLAN-EVAL. Hard rules: PLAN only — zero implementation, no self-eval, no merging, no lockfile changes, no deno cache --reload.

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T11:15:57Z

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27465201406-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27465201406-1

OpenHands Summary — [5d5] `@netscript/fresh/form` PLAN phase

Run: 27465201406-1 · Branch: feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form · PR #38

Summary

Completed the PLAN-phase deliverables for Wave 5d sub-gate 5/6: @netscript/fresh/form RFC 15 forms consuming fresh-ui seams. Zero implementation. Artifacts are committed to the branch and ready for PLAN-EVAL.

Changes

Artifact	Path	Status	Commit
design.md	`.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/design.md`	new	`3ae538c`
plan.md	`.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/plan.md`	new	`3ae538c`
context-pack.md	`.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/context-pack.md`	new	`3ae538c`
drift.md	`.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/drift.md`	updated	`3ae538c`
commits.md	`.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/commits.md`	updated	`499d4e9`

No source files were modified. No lockfile changes.

Validation

Static baseline preserved from research.md; no checks re-run per instructions.
All deliverable files exist, are committed, and follow the handover "Concept of done (PLAN phase)".
plan.md ends with the required sections: Review map, Assumptions, Questions for supervisor, Dependencies & merge impact, Side-effect ledger.

MEASURE-FIRST table

Metric	Value
`deno doc --lint` total	74
`missing-jsdoc`	60
`private-type-ref`	11
`missing-return-type` (doc lint)	3
`deno publish --dry-run` problems	62
`excluded-module` errors	58
`missing-explicit-return-type` (dry-run)	4
Over-cap files	3 (`schema-adapter.ts` 576, `field-descriptors.ts` 518, `types.ts` 474)

Slice count

30 locked slices (including 2 reserved buffers).

Gate-to-slice map highlights

Gate	Slices
F-1 File-size lint	2, 3, 4
F-5 Public surface audit	2, 5, 6, 8, 9, 10, 11
F-6 JSR publishability	23 (scoped; residual D-5d5-1)
F-7 Doc-score gate	1, 6, 9, 11, 12, 25
F-18 Sub-barrel lint	3, 4
Static doc lint / typecheck	2, 22
Browser validation	15, 16, 17, 18, 19, 20
Consumer import	15, 25

Full map is in plan.md.

Top decisions / risks

Decompose schema-adapter.ts, field-descriptors.ts, and types.ts while preserving public exports.
Add createStandardSchemaAdapter for Standard Schema interop; Zod adapter rebuilt on top.
Keep fresh↔fresh-ui seam value-level (no cross-package imports); optional htmlFor prop proposed for ergonomic label association.
Progressive enhancement: no-JS server reply + islands upgrade path; playground route proves both.
Root workspace packages/fresh/ exclusion is out of scope for 5d5; tracked as D-5d5-1 for umbrella 5d6.

Remaining risks

Supervisor may reject optional fresh-ui htmlFor slice; fallback documented.
Standard Schema error-shape parity must be proven during implementation (slices 9–11).
Internal barrels need explicit // arch:barrel-ok justification during implementation.
5d4 branch state unknown; slice 0 is reserved for merge/rebase.

READY FOR PLAN-EVAL.

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27465201406

- design.md: file decomposition + fresh<->fresh-ui seam contract + Standard Schema verdict + progressive enhancement strategy - plan.md: 30-slice lock with per-slice gates + full F-1..F-18 / browser gate-to-slice map - context-pack.md: current state, decisions, questions, side-effect ledger - drift.md: D-5d5-2..D-5d5-5 added No implementation. No lockfile changes. Co-Authored-By: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code <noreply@anthropic.com>

Co-Authored-By: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code <noreply@anthropic.com>

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T12:08:23Z

@openhands-agent model=openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max output=pr-comment iterations=400 use harness

Activate SKILL

netscript-harness
netscript-doctrine
jsr-audit
deno-fresh
frontend-design
ux-patterns

PLAN-EVAL — independent evaluator session for [5d5 form — RFC 15 forms consuming fresh-ui]. The PLAN generator committed design.md (147 lines) + plan.md (305 lines) + research.md + context-pack.md to .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/ on this branch. You are the INDEPENDENT evaluator — you did not write these.

Verify (binary PASS/FAIL each):

the form/ decomposition target is DECIDED (module split + file responsibilities), not left as options.
the fresh<->fresh-ui SEAM is specified: form-field.tsx / control-props.ts / l0-conventions.md state + the data-*/ARIA contract between the form layer and the UI primitives.
the Standard Schema interop choice is MADE (zod / valibot / arktype) with measurement-grounded rationale and a single canonical adapter, not deferred.
the progressive-enhancement strategy (no-JS form submit + island hydration) is decided and consistent with RFC 15.
design.md resolves every D-5d5-n decision the research handed off (no open decisions leaking into IMPL), and the plan's slices retire the doc-lint / private-type-ref budgets cited in research.md.

CRITICAL gate check (this was the sibling 5d4 failure mode): does plan.md's fitness-gate table list EVERY gate the archetype requires per .llm/harness/gates/archetype-gate-matrix.md? Flag any required gate omitted WITHOUT N/A rationale. Confirm each applicable gate is mapped to a slice and the slice numbers in the gate table match the actual commit-slice lock (no off-by-one). Reconcile the doc-lint / over-cap / private-type-ref budgets against the committed measurement artifacts, and confirm drift.md does not reference sections/locks/slices absent from plan.md.

Evaluate against .llm/harness/evaluator/plan-protocol.md, the gate matrix, the BINDING umbrella plan.md (.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d-fresh/plan.md), and handover-5d5-plan.md.

Output: commit plan-eval.md to the run dir (binary PASS/FAIL per item + gate-by-gate findings). Summary via OPENHANDS_SUMMARY_PATH ending with EXACTLY one verdict line: VERDICT: APPROVED or VERDICT: NEEDS-REVISION + remaining blockers. Evaluation ONLY — zero edits to plan/design/research, no implementation, no merging. Do NOT emit any @openhands-agent block.

rickylabs · 2026-06-13T12:08:39Z

OpenHands Agent — Completed

Model: openrouter/qwen/qwen3.7-max
Provider: OPENROUTER
Job status: success
Trace: .llm/tmp/run/openhands/pr-38/run-27466343559-1 (committed to the PR branch)
Artifact: openhands-agent-27466343559-1

PLAN-EVAL Summary — 5d5-form

Summary

Independent PLAN-EVAL evaluation of the 5d5-form plan artifacts (design.md, plan.md, research.md, drift.md, context-pack.md) committed to .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/ on branch feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form (PR #38).

Evaluation scope: 5 task-defined criteria + Plan-Gate checklist (8 items) + gate-by-gate reconciliation (F-1 through F-18, static/runtime/browser/consumer gates) + budget reconciliation + drift.md integrity check.

Evaluation result: APPROVED — all criteria satisfied, no blockers identified.

Changes

Created .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/plan-eval.md (224 lines)
- Binary PASS/FAIL verdicts for 5 task-defined criteria
- Plan-Gate checklist evaluation (8 items, all PASS)
- Gate-by-gate reconciliation table (F-1 through F-18, static, runtime, browser, consumer)
- Budget reconciliation against research.md MEASURE-FIRST measurements
- drift.md integrity check
- Open-decision sweep (none found that would force rework if deferred)
- Implementation readiness statement

Validation

Task-defined criteria (binary PASS/FAIL)

Criterion	Verdict	Evidence
1. Form decomposition DECIDED	PASS	design.md §3.1 definitive split table; plan.md slices 2-4 commit to decomposition
2. fresh ↔ fresh-ui SEAM specified	PASS	design.md §3.2 mapping table; research.md §4 exhaustive seam analysis; data-*/ARIA contract documented
3. Standard Schema interop choice MADE	PASS	design.md §3.3 locks Standard Schema v1; single canonical adapter `createStandardSchemaAdapter`; measurement-grounded rationale cites Remix/Next.js/TanStack Form market bar
4. Progressive enhancement strategy decided	PASS	design.md §3.4 HTML-first + island hydration; plan.md slices 15-20 prove no-JS submit, enhanced submit, errors, pending, CSRF, responsive
5. design.md resolves D-5d5-n decisions	PASS	drift.md D-5d5-1 through D-5d5-5 all resolved or explicitly deferred with rationale; open-decision sweep lists 4 decisions, none would force rework

Plan-Gate checklist

Item	Verdict	Evidence
Research present and current	PASS	research.md exists; re-baselined against current branch
Decisions locked	PASS	design.md §3.1-3.4 locks 4 major decisions; plan.md "Locked Decisions" table
Open-decision sweep	PASS	plan.md line 72-80 lists 4 open decisions; all safe to defer
Commit slices (< 30, gate + files each)	PASS	30 slices (0-29 including 2 buffers); each names files, gates, budget
Risk register	PASS	plan.md line 81-90 lists 5 risks; design.md §6 lists 6 risks
Gate set selected	PASS	F-1-F-18, static, runtime/browser/consumer gates all selected from archetype-gate-matrix.md A3 + SCOPE-frontend
Deferred scope explicit	PASS	plan.md Non-Scope section lists 5 deferred items with rationale
jsr-audit surface scan	PASS	research.md §1-2 performs jsr-audit; 62 dry-run problems, 58 excluded-module (D-5d5-1 tracked), 4 missing-explicit-return-type (slice 5)

Gate-by-gate reconciliation

Fitness gates (F-1 through F-18): All 18 gates present and mapped to slices. F-13 (Saga/runtime invariants) marked n/a with rationale ("No sagas/workers in form package") — acceptable vacuous satisfaction.

Static gates: All 7 gates present (narrow typecheck, slice typecheck, format, lint, doc lint, publish dry-run, link/path check).

Runtime / Browser / Consumer gates: All 8 gates present (failure path, route check, browser validation, loading/empty/error states, responsive, contract check, package imports, README examples).

Omitted gates: None. No required gate omitted without N/A rationale.

Slice numbering consistency: Plan uses 0-29 (30 slices). Gate-to-slice map references slices 1-27 and "all slices". No off-by-one errors detected.

Budget reconciliation

Budget	Baseline (research.md)	Slices retiring	Verdict
doc-lint errors	74	2 (62→0), 5 (12→0), 6 (JSDoc sweep)	PASS
private-type-ref	11	2 (re-export/narrow all 11)	PASS
missing-return-type (doc lint)	3	5 (add return types)	PASS
missing-explicit-return-type (dry-run)	4	5 (add return types)	PASS
Over-cap files (>475 LOC)	3	2 (types.ts ≤300), 3 (field-descriptors split), 4 (schema-adapter split)	PASS

All budgets reconcile against research.md MEASURE-FIRST measurements. Measurement artifacts archived (deno-doc-lint.txt, dry-run-raw.txt, publish-dry-run-form.txt, form-doc.json, form-symbols.json).

drift.md integrity check

All drift items (D-5d5-1 through D-5d5-5) reference plan.md sections/slides/budgets that exist. No phantom references. Drift items traceable to plan.md "Locked Decisions", "Open-Decision Sweep", and slice descriptions.

Verdict: PASS — drift.md integrity maintained.

Responses to review comments

N/A — this is the PLAN-EVAL evaluation, not a code review response.

Remaining risks

5d4 dependency (slice 0): 5d5 implementation cannot begin until 5d4 lands on the umbrella branch and slice 0 (rebase/merge) completes successfully. If 5d4 has conflicts or delays, 5d5 timeline shifts accordingly. Mitigation: Plan explicitly states slice 0 = merge 5d4 into 5d5 branch and re-baseline; if conflict, escalate.
Optional htmlFor prop (slice 13): Marked optional in plan. If supervisor rejects during implementation, plan documents fallback (name={field.id}). Impact: Low — seam works without it; recipe documents the workaround.
Root workspace exclusion (D-5d5-1): Deferred to 5d6. 5d5 cannot deliver JSR publishability for @netscript/fresh/form until 5d6 removes packages/fresh/ from root deno.json exclude. Impact: Acceptable — 5d5 retires form-internal gates (doc-lint, file-size, type-safety) so 5d6 can lift the exclusion cleanly.
Standard Schema error-shape parity (D-5d5-3): createStandardSchemaAdapter may produce different error messages than current Zod-only adapter. Mitigation: Plan slices 9-11 include unit tests proving toFormErrors parity for representative Zod schemas; README migration note (slice 1).
Valibot/ArkType introspection adapters: Deferred to follow-up slices. Impact: Low — Standard Schema validation works for all three libraries; constraint introspection is only needed for HTML constraint derivation (Zod introspector is sufficient for 5d5).
Client-side async validation: Deferred to follow-up slices. Impact: Low — server-side validation via Standard Schema is the 5d5 deliverable; client-side validation is an enhancement.
Playground route scope: Plan resolves as "one route covers all five browser gates" (open-decision sweep line 79). Risk: If supervisor wants separate routes for no-JS vs enhanced, slice 15 may need adjustment. Mitigation: Open-decision sweep marks this as "must resolve during slice 1" — early resolution prevents rework.

Implementation readiness

VERDICT: APPROVED

All 5 task-defined criteria satisfied. All 8 Plan-Gate checklist items satisfied. All required fitness gates (F-1 through F-18), static gates, runtime/browser/consumer gates present and mapped to slices. Slice numbering consistent (no off-by-one). Budgets reconcile against research.md measurements and measurement artifacts. drift.md integrity maintained.

Implementation may begin after:

5d4 lands on the umbrella branch (feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d-fresh)
Slice 0 (rebase/merge 5d4 into 5d5 branch) completes successfully
Baseline checks re-run to confirm no conflicts

No plan revisions required. No blockers identified.

VERDICT: APPROVED

Run: https://github.com/rickylabs/netscript/actions/runs/27466343559

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T01:54:20Z

Slice 7: Telemetry alignment

Commits

91e8e17 — [5d5] Slice 7 align form telemetry
abc70b7 — [5d5] Record slice 7 commit

Files changed

packages/fresh/form/telemetry.ts
- Delegates form telemetry to the shared Fresh convention in packages/fresh/_internal/telemetry.ts.
- Preserves withFormSpan and emitFormError signatures.
- Emits normalized scope: 'form', form.phase, and netscript.operation attributes.
packages/fresh/builders/define-page/builder/mod.tsx
- Removes duplicate submit-failure console.error; structured telemetry plus normalizeFormError remain the failure path.
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/worklog.md
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/context-pack.md
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/commits.md

Gates and results

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx — PASS, 0 occurrences
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/telemetry.ts packages/fresh/builders/define-page/builder/mod.tsx — PASS
deno fmt --check packages/fresh/form/telemetry.ts packages/fresh/builders/define-page/builder/mod.tsx — PASS
deno lint packages/fresh/form/telemetry.ts packages/fresh/builders/define-page/builder/mod.tsx — PASS
grep -R "console\." -n packages/fresh/form packages/fresh/builders/define-page/builder/mod.tsx | head -80 — PASS, no matches
find packages/fresh/form -name '*.ts' -o -name '*.tsx' | xargs wc -l | sort -nr | head -30 — PASS, telemetry.ts 64 LOC and no over-cap form files

Residual risks

_internal/telemetry.ts behavior is covered by existing support-spine tests; this slice did not add a form-specific telemetry unit test because it preserves the existing form helper API and only changes delegation.
deno fmt --check did not accept .llm/tmp Markdown paths as target files in this environment; TypeScript touched-file formatting passed.
rtk was not available on PATH, so this slice used raw focused commands and checked-in wrappers.

Next slice

Slice 8: mod.ts public surface audit, preserving all public export names and import paths.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T01:57:23Z

Slice 8: `mod.ts` public surface audit

Commits

6fe4fbe — [5d5] Slice 8 audit form public surface
ad4a3d9 — [5d5] Record slice 8 commit

Files changed

.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/worklog.md
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/context-pack.md
.llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/commits.md

No source files changed in this slice; it is a verification-only public-surface audit.

Audit result

deno doc --json packages/fresh/form/mod.ts reports 78 public symbols, counting value exports and exported types.
Missing declaration docs: 0.
Upstream declaration leaks: 0.
Deno doc-lint private-type-ref: 0.
Deno JSON still reports 42 public type declarations from _internal/*-types.ts; this is expected from Slice 2’s public type-manifest split. types.ts publicly re-exports those author-facing names while implementation declarations live in focused internal files. No consumer import path or public export name changed.

Gates and results

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx — PASS, 0 occurrences
deno doc --json packages/fresh/form/mod.ts parsed for symbol count, missing docs, internal declarations, and upstream declarations — PASS, 78 symbols, 0 missing docs, 0 upstream declarations, 42 expected _internal declarations
deno fmt --check packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
grep -R "export .*from ['\"]\(npm:\|jsr:\|zod\|@std/\|fresh\|preact\)" -n packages/fresh/form/mod.ts packages/fresh/form/*.ts packages/fresh/form/*.tsx | head -80 — PASS, no matches
find packages/fresh/form -name '*.ts' -o -name '*.tsx' | xargs wc -l | sort -nr | head -30 — PASS, mod.ts 93 LOC and no over-cap form files

Residual risks

Public type declarations still resolve to _internal/*-types.ts in Deno doc JSON because the source declarations live there by design. This is not a current deno doc --lint failure and does not change import paths.
rtk is still not available on PATH in this session, so raw focused commands and checked-in wrappers were used.

Next slice

Slice 9: schema adapter additive work only if gates remain clean and the public surface remains stable.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:10:12Z

Slice 9: Standard Schema adapter

Commits pushed:

25e7bc2 [5d5] Slice 9 add standard schema adapter
300cc25 [5d5] Record slice 9 commit
e42f4aa [5d5] Fix slice 9 ledger hash

What changed:

Added createStandardSchemaAdapter for Standard Schema v1 compatible schemas.
Added package-owned Standard Schema contract types and exports through form/schema-adapter.ts and form/mod.ts.
Added schema-adapter-standard.test.ts coverage for success, field/form error normalization, aggregate parse errors, and Zod Standard Schema metadata compatibility.
Kept createZodAdapter on the existing deep form/schema-adapter.ts path, but did not add it to root form/mod.ts, avoiding Zod private-type leaks in public root doc-lint.
Documented schema-adapter result properties so public doc-lint stays clean.
Reverted incidental deno.lock churn from a root-config test run; package-config tests use the pinned zod import.

Validation:

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx PASS, 0 findings
deno test --config packages/fresh/deno.json --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter-standard.test.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.test.ts PASS, 18/0
touched-file deno fmt --check PASS
touched-file deno lint PASS
form file-size scan PASS; new files are ≤171 LOC

Continue with schema-adapter parity / follow-up slices, then final 5d5 readiness gates.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:16:46Z

5d5 Slice 10 — Zod adapter Standard Schema rebuild

Pushed Slice 10 to feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form:

22b964d — [5d5] Slice 10 rebuild zod adapter
7fe2963 — [5d5] Record slice 10 commit

What changed:

Rebuilt createZodAdapter validation on the Zod schema's Standard Schema ~standard.validate() path.
Preserved the existing public signature and form/schema-adapter.ts import path.
Preserved Zod-specific behavior: parse() still rejects with ZodError, safeParse() still normalizes through z.flattenError(...), and defaults/constraints remain handled by the Zod introspector helpers.
Added focused regression tests proving both safeParse() and parse() avoid the public safeParseAsync() method and validate through Standard Schema metadata.

Gates run:

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx — PASS
deno test --config packages/fresh/deno.json --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.test.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter-standard.test.ts — PASS, 20 passed / 0 failed
deno fmt --check packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/zod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.test.ts — PASS
deno lint packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/zod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.test.ts — PASS
file-size scan — PASS; touched test file is 439 LOC and no form file is over cap

Next planned slice: Slice 11 schema introspector contract, only if it remains additive and public doc-lint stays clean.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:20:31Z

5d5 Slice 11 — Schema introspector contract

Pushed Slice 11 to feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form:

3a11750 — [5d5] Slice 11 add schema introspector contract
9921aef — [5d5] Record slice 11 commit

What changed:

Added additive SchemaIntrospector<TSchema, TValues> in packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/contract.ts.
Exported the type through schema-adapter/mod.ts, the schema-adapter.ts compatibility facade, and the root form/mod.ts manifest.
Updated the form README and architecture docs to describe the current Standard Schema validation path plus vendor-specific metadata introspection for constraints/defaults.
No runtime adapter behavior changed and no upstream schema package is re-exported.

Gates run:

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx — PASS
deno test --config packages/fresh/deno.json --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.test.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter-standard.test.ts — PASS, 20 passed / 0 failed
deno fmt --check packages/fresh/form/mod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/mod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/contract.ts packages/fresh/form/README.md packages/fresh/docs/form/architecture.md — PASS
deno lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/mod.ts packages/fresh/form/schema-adapter/contract.ts — PASS
file-size scan — PASS; no form file over cap

Next planned slice: Slice 12 fresh-ui seam docs, only if package gates stay clean.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:23:28Z

5d5 Slice 12 — Fresh UI seam recipe refresh

Pushed Slice 12 to feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form:

395bab5 — [5d5] Slice 12 refresh fresh-ui seam recipe
142eaf0 — [5d5] Record slice 12 commit

What changed:

Updated packages/fresh/docs/form/fresh-ui-recipe.md as a docs-only seam slice.
Clarified that @netscript/fresh/form and @netscript/fresh-ui compose through copied registry components and descriptor values, not package imports.
Corrected the copied registry example paths to components/ui/control-props.ts and components/ui/form-field.tsx, matching the current registry sources.
Added Standard Schema / SchemaIntrospector guidance so Fresh UI consumers treat descriptor props as the source of truth instead of inspecting upstream schema libraries.
No playground/browser slice was attempted because this worktree has no apps/playground directory.

Gates run:

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts — PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx — PASS
deno fmt --check packages/fresh/docs/form/fresh-ui-recipe.md — PASS
link/path existence for packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/control-props.ts, packages/fresh-ui/registry/components/ui/form-field.tsx, and packages/fresh/docs/form/fresh-ui-recipe.md — PASS
file-size scan — PASS; no form file over cap

Next: scoped 5d5 closeout gates and ready-for-IMPL-EVAL handoff. Full CLI E2E remains intentionally unrun per protocol.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:29:33Z

5d5 final closeout: ready for IMPL-EVAL

Status: implementation slices 1-12 plus final scoped closeout are committed and pushed.

Commits pushed since slice 12:

a461644 [5d5] Final scoped closeout
a5e0cd7 [5d5] Record final closeout commit

Final closeout evidence from /home/codex/repos/netscript-wave5-apps-5d5-form:

deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts PASS
deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx PASS
deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx PASS
deno test --allow-env --config packages/fresh/deno.json --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form PASS: 53 passed, 0 failed
(cd packages/fresh && deno task dry-run) PASS
file-size scan PASS: largest form file is schema-adapter.test.ts at 439 LOC
console scan PASS: no console. matches under packages/fresh/form
upstream public re-export scan PASS: no external upstream re-exports from form public surface
folder vocabulary PASS: form, _internal, field-descriptors, schema-adapter

Drift status:

Closed: D-5d5-3 Standard Schema adapter parity, D-5d5-4 internal barrel justification, D-5d5-5 scoped form checks.
Still open by design: D-5d5-1 root workspace check exclusion ownership is deferred to 5d6/umbrella; D-5d5-2 optional fresh-ui htmlFor/browser route proof remains follow-up because this branch does not own a runnable app playground.

Full CLI E2E was not run for this slice handoff by design; reserve deno task e2e:cli run scaffold.runtime --cleanup --format pretty for merge-readiness/full CLI E2E gates.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:35:29Z

IMPL-EVAL summary: 5d5 form

Verdict: PASS

Evaluator artifact commit: 40693c9 (eval(5d5): record form verdict)

Scope verified

Evaluator ran from /home/codex/repos/netscript-wave5-apps-5d5-form on feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form.
Branch started clean and was current with origin/feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form after fetch.
Final closeout commits did not hide source churn outside 5d5 scope: a461644 touched run drift/worklog plus four form test formatting files; a5e0cd7 touched commits.md; a590187 added the evaluator prompt.
No deno.lock churn was present after evaluator gates.

Gates run

PASS: deno doc --lint packages/fresh/form/mod.ts
PASS: deno check --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form/mod.ts
PASS: deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-check.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx
PASS: deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-fmt.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx
PASS: deno run --allow-read --allow-run .llm/tools/run-deno-lint.ts --root packages/fresh/form --ext ts,tsx
PASS: deno test --allow-env --config packages/fresh/deno.json --unstable-kv packages/fresh/form (53 passed, 0 failed)
PASS: (cd packages/fresh && deno task dry-run) (Success Dry run complete)

Doctrine/public surface checks

PASS: no external upstream re-export leaks from packages/fresh/form/mod.ts or form adapter/descriptor surfaces.
PASS: internal barrels have // arch:barrel-ok justifications.
PASS: all form files are within accepted 5d5 drift; largest is schema-adapter.test.ts at 439 LOC.
PASS: Standard Schema and Zod adapter behavior has focused test coverage, including error normalization and ~standard.validate() parity.

Residual risks

D-5d5-1 remains open for umbrella/5d6 root workspace exclusion ownership; it does not block this 5d5 source slice.
D-5d5-2 remains open for optional fresh-ui htmlFor / browser route proof. This worktree has no apps/playground, so the evaluator accepts it as non-blocking residual drift for 5d5. Supervisor merge-readiness should carry the browser proof forward if the integration branch provides the playground app.
rtk was unavailable on PATH in this WSL evaluator session, so raw git commands were used for branch/status evidence.

Full CLI E2E

Skipped by protocol. deno task e2e:cli run scaffold.runtime --cleanup --format pretty remains reserved for supervisor merge-readiness/full CLI E2E.

5d5 is ready for supervisor merge into feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d-fresh.

rickylabs · 2026-06-14T02:36:14Z

Supervisor confirmation: 5d5 IMPL-EVAL PASS

Observed evaluator result after separate app-server session from /home/codex/repos/netscript-wave5-apps-5d5-form.

Evaluator commit pushed:

40693c9 eval(5d5): record form verdict

Verdict:

PASS
5d5 is ready for supervisor merge into feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d-fresh.

Evaluator gate evidence recorded in .llm/tmp/run/feat-package-quality-wave5-apps--5d5-form/evaluate.md:

public doc lint PASS
narrow form typecheck PASS
scoped form check/fmt/lint PASS
full form tests PASS: 53 passed, 0 failed
packages/fresh dry-run PASS
lock hygiene and public surface checks PASS

Residual drift accepted open by evaluator:

D-5d5-1 root workspace check exclusion: deferred to umbrella/5d6 ownership.
D-5d5-2 optional fresh-ui/browser proof: non-blocking for 5d5 source slice; carry into integration merge-readiness if needed.

Full CLI E2E remains intentionally skipped for this PR-level eval and reserved for supervisor merge-readiness/full CLI E2E.

Seed harness run dir for 5d5-form (PLAN phase)

4ce9b26

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

rickylabs mentioned this pull request Jun 12, 2026

[Wave 5d] @netscript/fresh — umbrella: target architecture + 6 sub-gates (5d1…5d6) #40

Merged

rickylabs and others added 4 commits June 12, 2026 22:44

Merge 5d umbrella docs (binding plan + handover prompts) into 5d5-form

b6cb09a

Co-Authored-By: Claude Fable 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>

chore(openhands): record run trace 27442097563-1

9a70d80

chore(openhands): apply partial agent changes (agent outcome: cancelled)

04360db

chore(openhands): record run trace 27445678290-1

7ee74cd

openhands-agent added 2 commits June 12, 2026 23:31

chore(openhands): apply partial agent changes (agent outcome: failure)

88effae

chore(openhands): record run trace 27446387806-1

fa61fc2

openhands-agent added 2 commits June 13, 2026 09:57

chore(openhands): apply partial agent changes (agent outcome: failure)

ec3f5ab

chore(openhands): record run trace 27461621394-1

03cc7ac

openhands-agent added 4 commits June 13, 2026 10:48

research(5d5): fill Standard Schema landscape + market bar

cc96a26

Sources: schema-adapter.ts, types.ts; Standard Schema spec, Zod/Valibot/ ArkType docs, Remix/React Router/Next.js/TanStack Form docs. Co-Authored-By: openhands <openhands@all-hands.dev>

chore(openhands): record run trace 27463663659-1

9e36d4d

openhands-agent and others added 3 commits June 13, 2026 11:52

[5d5] record commit hash for PLAN artifact milestone

499d4e9

Co-Authored-By: openrouter/moonshotai/kimi-k2.7-code <noreply@anthropic.com>

chore(openhands): record run trace 27465201406-1

0614526

openhands-agent and others added 3 commits June 13, 2026 12:15

chore(openhands): apply agent changes

a7ca812

chore(openhands): record run trace 27466343559-1

d35fdde

fix(cli): support WSL scaffold copy fallback

c5852f8

rickylabs added 3 commits June 14, 2026 03:48

chore(5d5): record second continuation prompt

19f3527

[5d5] Slice 7 align form telemetry

91e8e17

[5d5] Record slice 7 commit

abc70b7

rickylabs added 2 commits June 14, 2026 03:56

[5d5] Slice 8 audit form public surface

6fe4fbe

[5d5] Record slice 8 commit

ad4a3d9

rickylabs added 3 commits June 14, 2026 04:09

[5d5] Slice 9 add standard schema adapter

25e7bc2

[5d5] Record slice 9 commit

300cc25

[5d5] Fix slice 9 ledger hash

e42f4aa

rickylabs added 3 commits June 14, 2026 04:10

chore(5d5): record final continuation prompt

9cbd550

[5d5] Slice 10 rebuild zod adapter

22b964d

[5d5] Record slice 10 commit

7fe2963

rickylabs added 2 commits June 14, 2026 04:19

[5d5] Slice 11 add schema introspector contract

3a11750

[5d5] Record slice 11 commit

9921aef

rickylabs added 2 commits June 14, 2026 04:22

[5d5] Slice 12 refresh fresh-ui seam recipe

395bab5

[5d5] Record slice 12 commit

142eaf0

rickylabs added 2 commits June 14, 2026 04:28

[5d5] Final scoped closeout

a461644

[5d5] Record final closeout commit

a5e0cd7

rickylabs added 2 commits June 14, 2026 04:30

chore(5d5): record evaluator prompt

a590187

eval(5d5): record form verdict

40693c9

rickylabs merged commit 8a3298d into feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d-fresh Jun 14, 2026

rickylabs deleted the feat/package-quality-wave5-apps-5d5-form branch June 22, 2026 21:34

Conversation

rickylabs commented Jun 12, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 12, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 12, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

OpenHands Agent — Agent failed

OpenHands Agent Summary — INCOMPLETE (iteration limit)

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

OpenHands Agent — Agent failed

OpenHands Agent Summary — INCOMPLETE (iteration limit)

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OpenHands Run Summary — [5d5] fresh form research completion

Summary

Markers filled

Sources cited

Changes

Validation

Responses to review comments or issue comments

Remaining risks

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

OpenHands Agent — Completed

OpenHands Summary — [5d5] @netscript/fresh/form PLAN phase

Summary

Changes

Validation

MEASURE-FIRST table

Slice count

Gate-to-slice map highlights

Top decisions / risks

Remaining risks

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 • edited Loading Uh oh! There was an error while loading. Please reload this page.

Uh oh!

OpenHands Agent — Completed

PLAN-EVAL Summary — 5d5-form

Summary

Changes

Validation

Task-defined criteria (binary PASS/FAIL)

Plan-Gate checklist

Gate-by-gate reconciliation

Budget reconciliation

drift.md integrity check

Responses to review comments

Remaining risks

Implementation readiness

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

Slice 7: Telemetry alignment

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

Slice 8: mod.ts public surface audit

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

Slice 9: Standard Schema adapter

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

5d5 Slice 10 — Zod adapter Standard Schema rebuild

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

5d5 Slice 11 — Schema introspector contract

Uh oh!

rickylabs commented Jun 14, 2026

rickylabs commented Jun 12, 2026 •

edited

Loading

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 •

edited

Loading

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 •

edited

Loading

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 •

edited

Loading

OpenHands Summary — [5d5] `@netscript/fresh/form` PLAN phase

rickylabs commented Jun 13, 2026 •

edited

Loading

Slice 8: `mod.ts` public surface audit