Skip to content

Submission: checklist audit fixes, compute section, kit \affiliations errors - #148

Merged
duckyquang merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
quang/repro-checklist
Jul 29, 2026
Merged

Submission: checklist audit fixes, compute section, kit \affiliations errors#148
duckyquang merged 1 commit into
mainfrom
quang/repro-checklist

Conversation

@duckyquang

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Member

Summary

Deadline-critical fixes to the submission package. Audited the filled AAAI-27 reproducibility checklist against the repo and fixed what didn't hold, plus two kit compile errors that would get the paper returned:

  • Both main.tex and supplement.tex errored at \maketitle — the aaai2027 kit requires \affiliations{} (empty for anonymous submissions) and neither file had it. AAAI recompiles sources and returns papers that error. Fixed; all three documents now compile with zero errors.
  • Checklist 4.8 ("computing infrastructure specified") said yes but nothing in the shipped tex stated it. The supplement now has a Compute and Software Environment section (M1 Pro 10-core / 16 GB / CPU-only, pinned versions, representative wall-clocks, the CI verify entry point) — the answer is now true instead of downgraded.
  • Checklist 2.3 ("novel claims stated formally, e.g. theorem statements") downgraded yes → partial — the paper's "theorem" mentions are prose claims about CAS certificates; only the best-of-K equation is formally stated. A false yes here is the kind of thing checklist-checking reviewers flag.

Result

  • main.tex: 0 errors, 8 pages (7 content + refs) · supplement.tex: 0 errors, 4 pages · ReproducibilityChecklist.tex: 0 errors, 2 pages
  • verify_paper_numbers: 52/52

Notes

@ImSpxrsh if you disagree on 2.3, it's a one-word revert — but partial is the safe answer under checklist scrutiny. Everything else is additive.

…ors fixed

Three fixes against the filled AAAI-27 reproducibility checklist, verified
against the repo: (1) item 4.8 claimed the paper specifies the computing
infrastructure but no shipped tex stated it — the supplement now carries a
Compute and Software Environment section (M1 Pro 10-core, 16 GB, CPU-only;
pinned library versions; representative wall-clocks; CI verify entry point),
so the 'yes' is true; (2) item 2.3 downgraded yes -> partial — the paper's
'theorem' mentions are prose claims about CAS certificates, not formal
theorem statements, and only Eq. (best-of-K) is stated formally; (3) both
main.tex and supplement.tex were missing the kit-required \affiliations{}
(empty, per the anonymous-submission instructions) and errored at \maketitle
— AAAI recompiles sources and returns papers that error. All three documents
now compile with zero errors (main 8pp incl. refs, supplement 4pp, checklist
2pp); 52/52 number guards pass.
@duckyquang
duckyquang requested a review from ImSpxrsh July 29, 2026 12:10
@duckyquang
duckyquang merged commit 6cc2679 into main Jul 29, 2026
1 check passed
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant