Skip to content

refactor(skill-docs): harden generator and make output deterministic#236

Merged
schpet merged 16 commits into
schpet:mainfrom
edwinhern:refactor/generate-docs-robustness
Jul 14, 2026
Merged

refactor(skill-docs): harden generator and make output deterministic#236
schpet merged 16 commits into
schpet:mainfrom
edwinhern:refactor/generate-docs-robustness

Conversation

@edwinhern

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

This reworks skills/linear-cli/scripts/generate-docs.ts for robustness and stable output, and regenerates the references with the new ordering.

Robustness:

  • run() now catches the error Deno.Command throws when a binary is missing (e.g. NotFound) instead of crashing, returning a failed result.
  • Help-fetch failures are collected and the run aborts before writing, so an error string can never be embedded into committed docs.
  • Reference files are written before stale ones are pruned, so a partial failure can no longer gut the references/ directory.
  • main() runs under an import.meta.main guard with a .catch that logs and exits non-zero.
  • The two pop() non-null assertions are replaced with a safe lastSegment() helper.

Output stability:

  • Top-level commands and each subcommand list are sorted by name before rendering, so generation is deterministic and stops producing reordering churn between runs (related to the motivation behind dropping the staleness check in ci: drop skill docs staleness check, keep generation smoke test #218). This is the source of the large but reorder-only docs diff in this PR. Happy to drop the sort if you'd rather keep CLI help order.

Cleanup:

  • The markdown builders are rewritten as pure map/join/flatMap helpers, and the unused formatCommandMarkdown helper is removed.

Verified with the repo-pinned Deno (2.7.9): deno fmt --check, deno lint, deno check, and deno task generate-skill-docs run twice with an empty diff between runs. The docs diff is reordering only (identical sorted line sets per file).

edwinhern and others added 16 commits June 26, 2026 13:06
Catch Deno.Command failures, abort before writing when any help fetch
fails, write reference files before pruning stale ones, and replace
non-null pop() assertions. Render docs from pure map/join/flatMap
helpers and sort commands by name so generated output is deterministic
and stops reordering between runs. Drops the unused formatCommandMarkdown
helper.
Image attachments uploaded via `issue attach` and `issue comment add
--attach` were sent with makePublic auto-detected to true for raster
images, producing a public.linear.app URL readable by anyone,
unauthenticated, with no way to opt out. This silently published
screenshots of internal data from private workspaces.

Default all uploads to private (uploads.linear.app), matching the Linear
web app. Add a --public flag to both commands to opt into a public URL,
which is only valid for raster images; requesting it for other types is
now an error rather than a silent downgrade. Print a warning whenever an
upload lands on a public URL.

Also document the attachment commands and their privacy behaviour in the
README (previously undocumented) and regenerate the skill reference.

Fixes schpet#233

Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
PR schpet#234 makes attachment uploads private by default and adds a --public
opt-in that errors (rather than silently downgrades) for non-image types.
Two gaps remained in `issue comment add`, both flagged independently while
blind-planning the fix:

- The public/type check only ran inside uploadFile, per file, at upload
  time. With `--public` and multiple attachments, an earlier valid image
  was uploaded *publicly* before a later non-image threw — a partial, and
  unwanted-public, upload. Pre-flight resolveMakePublic() for every
  attachment in the existing existence-validation loop so a mixed batch
  fails before anything is uploaded.
- `--public` with no `--attach` was a silent no-op. Per the repo's
  "explicit invalid input should error" convention, reject it.

Adds command-level tests for both validation paths (they short-circuit
before any network call, so no upload mock is needed).
## Why

Linear projects have two text fields: a short description and a longer
project overview. The CLI only supported the short description, so
projects created from the terminal still needed a manual edit in Linear
to add goals, plans, specs, or launch notes.

This PR lets users create a project with its overview already filled in,
either from inline markdown or a markdown file. That makes `linear
project create` more useful for scripted project setup, templates, and
project specs kept in a repo.

It also exposes a few existing Linear create fields so users can set
priority, labels, members, icon, and color when creating the project
instead of doing a follow-up edit.

## What changed

- `linear project create` now accepts `--content` for inline project
overview markdown.
- `--content-file` reads the project overview from a markdown file.
- `--content` and `--content-file` are mutually exclusive.
- Project create can now set priority, labels, members, icon, and color.
- The command passes these values through `ProjectCreateInput` using
Linear field names.

## Checks

- `deno task codegen`
- `deno task check`
- `deno lint`
- `deno task test`
PR schpet#216 adds --content/--content-file plus priority/label/member/icon/color
to `linear project create`, with happy-path snapshot tests and a
mutual-exclusion unit test. This adds the missing failure-path coverage that
both blind-planning passes called for:

- invalid --priority is rejected with a ValidationError before any network call
- an unknown --label surfaces a NotFoundError
- an unknown --member surfaces a NotFoundError

These use a stubbed Deno.exit and capture stderr (mirroring the validation
tests in issue-query.test.ts), and run against a mock Linear server so they
never touch the real API. No product code changes — the contributor's feature
is correct as written; this only locks in the error behavior.
milestone view silently capped its issues list at 10 items. A user with
12 issues would see only 10 and could miss issues entirely when
iterating over the visible output in a script. The cap was also
undocumented in --help.

- Request first: 50 issues with pageInfo on the connection.
- Add --all to paginate through every page when needed.
- Show a prominent truncation footer pointing at --all and at
  `linear issue query --milestone X --json` for full programmatic
  access.
- Document the default cap in --help.

Closes schpet#222
…pshots

schpet#228 fixes milestone view silently capping its issue list, adding --all to
paginate. Two corrections:

1. Fail loudly on inconsistent --all pagination. The loop guarded on
   `while (pageInfo.hasNextPage && pageInfo.endCursor)` and `if (next == null)
   break`, so if Linear advertised another page but returned no cursor (or the
   milestone vanished mid-pagination), --all would stop early and return a
   *partial* list with no error — reintroducing the exact silent-truncation bug
   this command exists to fix. Now throws CliError / NotFoundError instead, with
   a regression test.

2. Fix timezone-flaky snapshots. The new "Truncated" and "--all paginates" tests
   used midnight-UTC timestamps (2020-01-01T00:00:00Z) whose snapshots were
   generated in a US timezone, so `formatRelativeTime`'s toLocaleDateString
   fallback rendered 12/31/2019 there but 1/1/2020 under CI's UTC — failing CI
   (fork CI never ran, so it slipped through). Moved the fixtures to noon UTC so
   they render the same date in every timezone; verified passing under TZ=UTC and
   TZ=America/Los_Angeles.
## Summary

This makes Linear document comments visible to agents/automation and
prevents `linear document update` from silently orphaning inline comment
anchors.

- include paginated document comments in `linear document view <id>
--json`
- guard Markdown content updates when active inline document comments
are present
- allow top-level document comments to pass through, since they do not
carry losable inline anchors
- add `--force` to opt back into the existing replacement behavior when
the caller intentionally accepts the risk


## Background / related work

Closes schpet#230, which reports that document comments are currently
unreachable from the CLI and omitted from `document view --json`.

Related:

- schpet#219 added richer `document view` behavior for downloaded inline
images; this PR keeps normal/raw rendered views lean and only expands
`--json` with comment metadata.
- schpet#121 added the raw `linear api` GraphQL escape hatch. That is useful
for inspection, but it does not make `documentUpdate(content)` safe for
inline document comments.

## API limitation

This is intentionally a safety guard plus read fix, not a
comment-preserving writer.

From the schema used by this CLI:

- `Document.comments(...)` exposes document comments and
`Comment.quotedText`, which is enough to detect inline comments.
- `DocumentUpdateInput` only accepts Markdown `content` for document
body writes; it does not accept `contentState`/YJS/ProseMirror data or
comment anchor metadata.
- `CommentCreateInput`/`CommentUpdateInput` expose `quotedText`, but
live testing showed raw GraphQL `commentUpdate(quotedText: ...)` returns
success without recreating an inline anchor. Writing
`<linear-comment>`-style tags through `documentUpdate(content)` stores
literal text, not an anchor.

So the CLI cannot preserve or restore inline anchors through the public
GraphQL write path it uses. The best safe behavior here is to make
comments visible and convert silent data loss into an explicit stop.
`--force` remains the old replacement behavior behind an intentional
flag.

## Behavior

`linear document view <id> --json` now returns a flattened, paginated
`comments.nodes` list with fields useful to agents:

- `id`, `body`, `quotedText`, `documentContentId`
- timestamps / archive / resolution metadata
- `url`, `user`, and `parent.id`
- final `pageInfo`

`linear document update <id> --content...` now scans active document
comments page-by-page. It blocks only when it finds a comment with
`quotedText`, i.e. an inline comment anchor that can be detached by
replacing Markdown content. Top-level document comments with
`quotedText: null` do not block.

## Testing

- `deno task validate`
- `deno test --allow-all --quiet`

Full suite result locally: `338 passed`, `0 failed`, `5 ignored`.
…date guard

schpet#235 makes `document update` refuse a content replacement when the document has
active inline comments (whose anchors the replacement could orphan), with
--force to override, and exposes comments in `document view --json`. Two
corrections to the guard in document-update.ts:

- Exclude resolved/archived inline comments. The guard query only selected
  `quotedText`, so it blocked on ANY inline comment — including resolved
  (closed) threads whose anchor detaching loses no live context. It now also
  selects `resolvedAt`/`archivedAt` and ignores comments that are resolved or
  archived, so a closed thread no longer forces users to pass --force.
- Drop the hand-written `DocumentInlineComment*` interfaces in favor of the
  codegen-inferred type (`DocumentInlineCommentGuardQuery`), per the repo's
  no-`any`/typed-GraphQL convention. The annotation also breaks the circular
  result-type inference that the reused `after` cursor variable introduces
  (the reason the hand-written interface existed).

Adds a test that a resolved inline comment lets the update proceed without
--force.
## Summary

This improves `linear issue create` in three related areas:

- allow `--project` to keep issue creation interactive, the same way
`--parent` already does
- add optional project selection in interactive issue creation
- add configurable default self-assignment behavior for created issues

Before this change, `linear issue create --project "Dashboard"` skipped
interactive mode and failed with "Title is required when not using
interactive mode". With this PR, `--project` is treated as an
interactive-safe input, so users can preselect a project without also
needing `--title`.

Project prompting in interactive mode remains opt-in.
`issue_create_ask_project` defaults to `false`, so existing interactive
behavior is unchanged unless users explicitly enable the new prompt.

## Changes

- allow interactive issue creation when the only flags are `--project`,
`--parent`, or both
- add a team-scoped project picker during interactive issue creation
- gate the direct project prompt behind a new config option:
`issue_create_ask_project`
- keep `issue_create_ask_project = false` as the default, so project
selection stays out of the main interactive flow unless enabled
- when `issue_create_ask_project = false`, expose `Project` through the
existing "Add more fields" flow instead
- continue inheriting the parent issue's project when `--parent` is used
without an explicit `--project`
- allow explicit `--project` together with `--parent` and defer any
invalid combination checks to the Linear API
- add a new config option, `issue_create_assign_self`, with these modes:
  - `auto` (default): respect Linear's `autoAssignToSelf` setting
  - `always`: default-assign created issues to self
  - `never`: never default-assign created issues
- update docs for the new interactive behavior and config options

## Notes

- `issue_create_ask_project` defaults to `false`, so users who do not
set it will keep the previous interactive flow
- project selection only shows projects available to the selected team
- the interactive project picker is not shown when a parent issue is
present unless the project was explicitly provided
- explicit `--assignee`, the interactive assignee flow, and `--start`
still override the default assignment behavior

## Testing

- `deno task codegen`
- `deno task check`
- `deno lint`
- `deno fmt`
- `deno task generate-skill-docs`
- `deno test --allow-all --quiet test/config.test.ts`
- `deno test --allow-all --quiet
test/commands/issue/issue-create.test.ts`
Add `labels` field to the JSON output of `linear issue view --json`.

Each label includes `id`, `name`, and `color`.

## Example

```json
{
  "identifier": "P-51",
  "labels": [
    {
      "id": "031de1e8-...",
      "name": "Work",
      "color": "#4cb782"
    }
  ]
}

---------

Co-authored-by: Hyunsu Lim <hyunsu.lim01@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Luc Leray <luc.leray@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: c-99-e <268417377+c-99-e@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Al Johri <al.johri@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai.v.chiorean@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Peter Schilling <code@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai-chiorean@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Jeffrey Holm <jeff.holm@scale.com>
Co-authored-by: Paymahn Moghadasian <paymahn1@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Evan Jacobson <evanjacobson3@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: schpetbot <bot@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Alex Broekhof <alex@quilt.com>
Co-authored-by: Theo Gregory <theo@gregory.sh>
Co-authored-by: Bryan <bryandesigning@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Ryan Schumacher <j.r.schumacher@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Joseph <31323641+josephyooo@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Magnus Buvarp <magnus.buvarp@gmail.com>
schpet#170 adds `labels` to `issue view --json` by selecting them in both
GetIssueDetails and GetIssueDetailsWithComments. Its dedicated
labels-with-content test only exercises the --no-comments (GetIssueDetails)
path; the with-comments path was covered only with empty labels. Add a
--json (with comments) test carrying real labels so both fetchIssueDetailsRaw
code paths are verified to surface labels — the consistency both were meant to
guarantee.
…#229)

The CLI was inconsistent about whether --project and --milestone flags
accept a UUID, slug, or name depending on which command you called.
Several commands silently rejected one form with a misleading "not
found" error.

- Extend resolveProjectId to accept UUID, slug, or name uniformly.
- Add resolveMilestoneId that accepts a UUID directly, or a name when
--project is supplied so the milestone lookup can be scoped.
- Wire the resolvers into issue create/update/mine/query, milestone
create/update/list, and milestone view (which now also accepts an
optional --project for name-based lookup).
- Remove document create's duplicate local resolver in favor of the
shared one.
- Update --help to say "UUID, slug ID, or name" everywhere.

Closes schpet#221

---------

Co-authored-by: Theo Gregory <theo@gregory.sh>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Peter Schilling <code@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Bryan <bryandesigning@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Joseph <31323641+josephyooo@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Magnus Buvarp <magnus.buvarp@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Rengar Lee <Rengarlee@163.com>
Co-authored-by: Hyunsu Lim <hyunsu.lim01@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Luc Leray <luc.leray@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: c-99-e <268417377+c-99-e@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Al Johri <al.johri@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai.v.chiorean@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai-chiorean@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Jeffrey Holm <jeff.holm@scale.com>
Co-authored-by: Paymahn Moghadasian <paymahn1@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Evan Jacobson <evanjacobson3@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: schpetbot <bot@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Alex Broekhof <alex@quilt.com>
…pet#227)

The Linear API rejects project descriptions longer than 255 characters,
but the CLI didn't document the limit or offer a way to work around the
shell-quoting friction of long inline strings.

- Add --description-file to project create and project update, mirroring
document create's --content-file. Mutually exclusive with --description.
- Pre-validate description length client-side with a ValidationError
that points users at --description-file or attaching a Document, so they
don't have to wait for the API to reject the request.
- Update --help text on both commands to mention the 255-char limit.

Closes schpet#224

---------

Co-authored-by: Theo Gregory <theo@gregory.sh>
Co-authored-by: Claude Opus 4.8 (1M context) <noreply@anthropic.com>
Co-authored-by: Peter Schilling <code@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Bryan <bryandesigning@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Joseph <31323641+josephyooo@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Magnus Buvarp <magnus.buvarp@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Rengar Lee <Rengarlee@163.com>
Co-authored-by: Hyunsu Lim <hyunsu.lim01@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Luc Leray <luc.leray@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: c-99-e <268417377+c-99-e@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Al Johri <al.johri@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai.v.chiorean@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Mihai Chiorean <mihai-chiorean@users.noreply.github.com>
Co-authored-by: Jeffrey Holm <jeff.holm@scale.com>
Co-authored-by: Paymahn Moghadasian <paymahn1@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: Evan Jacobson <evanjacobson3@gmail.com>
Co-authored-by: schpetbot <bot@schpet.com>
Co-authored-by: Alex Broekhof <alex@quilt.com>
Regenerated skill docs with the PR's new deterministic generator against
current main (post schpet#227/schpet#170/schpet#229) so the sorted output reflects the latest
CLI surface and no longer conflicts with trunk.
@schpet
schpet merged commit ffb986d into schpet:main Jul 14, 2026
schpet added a commit that referenced this pull request Jul 14, 2026
… SKILL.md first

Corrective delta on top of #236's generator hardening:

- deno fmt failure is now fatal instead of a logged warning; unformatted
  committed docs would otherwise break `deno fmt --check` in CI.
- The top-level error boundary prints a concise message instead of the raw
  error (and its stack trace) on every abort path.
- SKILL.md is rendered from its template before writeReferences prunes any
  stale docs, so a missing or broken template aborts before touching the
  references directory.
schpet added a commit that referenced this pull request Jul 14, 2026
… SKILL.md first

Corrective delta on top of #236's generator hardening:

- deno fmt failure is now fatal instead of a logged warning; unformatted
  committed docs would otherwise break `deno fmt --check` in CI.
- The top-level error boundary prints a concise message instead of the raw
  error (and its stack trace) on every abort path.
- SKILL.md is rendered from its template before writeReferences prunes any
  stale docs, so a missing or broken template aborts before touching the
  references directory.
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

8 participants