Q) getnewblockhex parameter(commit_data)

[nueno4]

#762

I execute getnewblockhex command with parameters.
The third parameter commit_data is "(string, required)", so I use "".
But, it can run without commit_data parameter, and return a shorter hex string than "".
Is commit_data parameter is optional?

• commit_data="" (return string=1072 chars)

$ e-cli getnewblockhex 0 "{\"signblockscript\":\"0020f4c108370fdf22f0b9187ec04465ac0bd4f8ba18a6c113735340ce46a68ace5e\", \"max_block_witness\":187, \"fedpegscript\":\"51\", \"extension_space\":[\"02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f\"]}" ""
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

• no commit_data (return string=976 chars)

$ e-cli getnewblockhex 0 "{\"signblockscript\":\"0020f4c108370fdf22f0b9187ec04465ac0bd4f8ba18a6c113735340ce46a68ace5e\", \"max_block_witness\":187, \"fedpegscript\":\"51\", \"extension_space\":[\"02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f\"]}"
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

[instagibbs]

"required" is a mistake. It's entirely optional. Thanks for the report!

…

On Wed, Nov 13, 2019, 7:28 AM ueno ***@***.***> wrote: #762 <#762> I execute getnewblockhex command with parameters. The third parameter commit_data is "(string, required)", so I use "". But, it can run without commit_data parameter, and return a shorter hex string than "". Is commit_data parameter is optional? - commit_data="" (return string=1072 chars) $ e-cli getnewblockhex 0 "{\"signblockscript\":\"0020f4c108370fdf22f0b9187ec04465ac0bd4f8ba18a6c113735340ce46a68ace5e\", \"max_block_witness\":187, \"fedpegscript\":\"51\", \"extension_space\":[\"02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f\"]}" "" 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 - no commit_data (return string=976 chars) $ e-cli getnewblockhex 0 "{\"signblockscript\":\"0020f4c108370fdf22f0b9187ec04465ac0bd4f8ba18a6c113735340ce46a68ace5e\", \"max_block_witness\":187, \"fedpegscript\":\"51\", \"extension_space\":[\"02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f02fcba7ecf41bc7e1be4ee122d9d22e3333671eb0a3a87b5cdf099d59874e1940f\"]}" 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 — You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread. Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub <#775?email_source=notifications&email_token=ABMAFUZIU2I25D46NEJRZTDQTPXIVA5CNFSM4JM2UQB2YY3PNVWWK3TUL52HS4DFUVEXG43VMWVGG33NNVSW45C7NFSM4HY76H5Q>, or unsubscribe <https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/ABMAFU764MRY6XS7KE7SPHLQTPXIVANCNFSM4JM2UQBQ> .

[instagibbs]

It's a real issue, let's close it when it's fixed in master.