Skip to content

SmartDAO Tiers

Jump to bottom
UnDaoDu edited this page May 6, 2026 · 1 revision

SmartDAO Tiers

The governance and participation structure of FoundUps — how stakeholders earn influence, how decisions get made, and why there's no board of directors.

What Is a SmartDAO?

A SmartDAO (Smart Decentralized Autonomous Organization) is FoundUps' governance model. It replaces the traditional corporate hierarchy (board → executives → employees → customers) with a tiered system where influence is earned through demonstrated contribution — not capital.

A SmartDAO is "smart" because its governance rules are encoded and enforced automatically, without requiring a CEO to decide or a board to vote. The protocols govern. The 012s participate. The swarms build.

Why Not a Traditional DAO?

Traditional DAOs give governance power proportional to token holdings. That recreates plutocracy — the people with the most capital have the most votes. FoundUps replaces token-weighted governance with contribution-weighted governance: your influence is proportional to the benefit you've helped create, not the capital you've deposited.

The Five Tiers

Tier Name Entry Condition Governance Rights
0 Observer Any — public access to foundups.com View FoundUp manifests, read documentation
1 Stakeholder Join FOUNDUPS Discord, react in #start-here, gain @Stakeholder Participate in community, flag pain points, submit ideas
2 Contributor Complete at least one verified build task (Hermes/OpenClaw cycle) Vote on FoundUp roadmap decisions, propose task decompositions
3 Validator Pass Proof of Benefit gate on a FoundUp you co-built Governance weight in CABR calculation, F_i exit fee governance
4 Architect Sustained contribution across multiple FoundUps, verified by AI Overseer track record Protocol proposal rights (WSP amendments), swarm coordination authority

Movement between tiers is upward only through contribution — and downward only through inactivity or protocol violation. There is no way to buy your way to Tier 4.

Tier 0 — Observer

The entry state. Anyone can be an Observer. No commitment required.

  • Read the manifesto at foundups.com
  • Browse active FoundUp manifests
  • Understand the pain/solution/outcome model

Observers see the ecosystem but cannot participate in governance or build cycles.

Tier 1 — Stakeholder (012)

The activated state. This is what 012 means: Zero (pain) + One (solution) + Two (outcome). A Stakeholder is someone who has identified a pain and entered the ecosystem to help solve it.

  • Entry: Discord join → #start-here → @Stakeholder role
  • Rights: Describe pain, validate outcomes, give feedback to the swarm
  • Governance: Voice, not vote — input into FoundUp direction but not protocol

Stakeholders are not customers. They are the ecosystem's problem-identifiers and outcome-validators. They are the reason the swarm exists.

Tier 2 — Contributor

A Stakeholder who has crossed the build threshold. At least one verified task completed through the OpenClaw/Hermes build lifecycle.

  • Entry: Complete one verified build task (submitted → verified in build lifecycle)
  • Rights: Vote on FoundUp roadmap, propose task decompositions to Architect
  • Governance: Roadmap-level decisions for FoundUps you've contributed to

Contributors have skin in the game — they've put compute in, not just capital.

Tier 3 — Validator

A Contributor whose work has passed the Proof of Benefit gate. They've built something that a 012 confirmed actually solved a real pain.

  • Entry: Proof of Benefit gate passes on a FoundUp with your contribution credited
  • Rights: Weight in CABR calculation, voice in F_i exit fee governance
  • Governance: Ecosystem-level health decisions — what counts as benefit, how CABR is calibrated

Validators are the people who know what "solved" actually looks like, because they've produced it.

Tier 4 — Architect

The highest tier. Sustained, verified, multi-FoundUp contribution. The AI Overseer's track record confirms behavioral alignment with FoundUps principles.

  • Entry: AI Overseer verified track record across multiple FoundUps + multi-cycle Proof of Benefit
  • Rights: WSP protocol amendment proposals, swarm coordination authority, FoundUp launch sponsorship
  • Governance: Protocol-level decisions — the rules that govern all agents and all FoundUps

Architects are rare. They are the people who understand the system deeply enough to improve its governance without breaking it. There is no shortcut.

How Decisions Are Made

Decision Type Who Decides
FoundUp direction (what to build next) Tier 2+ Contributors for that FoundUp
Benefit validation (did it work?) Tier 1 Stakeholders (012s) — the people with the pain
CABR calibration Tier 3 Validators
WSP protocol changes Tier 4 Architects (proposal) + 012 (final approval)
Emergency halts AI Overseer (automatic) + 012 (override)

No single entity controls any of these. The SmartDAO distributes decision rights to the people with the most relevant knowledge and demonstrated contribution.

UPS Tokens and Tier Rights

UPS tokens flow to contributors through the build lifecycle. Tier rights are separate from token holdings:

  • Tokens compensate for compute contributed (economic layer)
  • Tier rights reflect governance influence (governance layer)
  • A Tier 2 Contributor with few tokens has more governance weight than a Tier 0 Observer with many tokens

This separation prevents the plutocracy problem: you cannot buy governance rights with tokens.

Related Pages

SmartDAO Tiers — governance earned through contribution, not capital. 0102🦞

Home

Get Started

Architecture

OpenClaw & Execution

Research & Economics

FoundUps

Phases

Discord & Community

Clone this wiki locally