Skip to content

Lit-review precipitation + drying methodology + interpretation backing (2/3) #61

@NewGraphEnvironment

Description

@NewGraphEnvironment

Problem

Vignette interpretation paragraphs in vignettes/peace-fwcp.Rmd and
vignettes/kootenay-lake.Rmd make defensible-sounding claims about
precipitation departure and "drying" — falling annual precipitation,
rising VPD/evapotranspiration, declining soil moisture, "soils drying
due to both ↓P and ↑ET" (the v0.1.1 finding) — but currently land on
zero peer-reviewed citations. For FWCP fish-passage reporting
context, these need the same cited backing #53/#54 gave Snowpack
and #58/#60 gave Temperature.

Scope

Second of three sequential climate-departure lit reviews covering
the non-snow vignette sections (3-split: temperature [done #58],
precip+drying [this issue], interpretation framing).
Mirrors the #58 / #54 / v0.1.7 pattern verbatim:

  • Targeted lit search → ~10 papers
  • Add to NewGraphEnvironment/climate Zotero collection (key
    8MH9LCC9), PDFs first per /lit-search policy
  • Build data/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdb ragnar store
  • Mine for methodology quotes; write findings.md with "cite this
    for that" map
  • Vignette [@key] insertion happens on a downstream branch, not here

Topics to cover

  1. Precipitation trend methodology — long-record analyses,
    homogenization, treatment of trace events
  2. Heavy / extreme precipitation — intensity-frequency-duration,
    anthropogenic attribution
  3. Orographic / mountain precipitation — rain-shadow gradients,
    Selkirk-Purcell type contrasts (relevant for Kootenay vignette)
  4. Vapor pressure deficit (VPD) + relative humidity — atmospheric
    evaporative demand driver
  5. Soil moisture as integrative drought signal — supply-demand
    balance, temperature acceleration of drying
  6. ERA5-Land precip / soil-moisture validation — bias structure
    (parallel to the snow-rag's Kouki 2023 for SWE)
  7. Drought-fish linkage — how summer-flow / soil-moisture deficit
    propagates to thermal habitat for salmonids

Starting candidate list (will refine)

Citation key (proposed) Topic / Why
donat_etal2013 HadEX2 Global temp + precip extremes dataset (J Geophys Res)
min_etal2011 Anthropogenic contribution to extreme precipitation (Nature)
mekis_vincent2011 Adjusted daily Canadian precipitation dataset (Atmos-Ocean)
daly_etal2008 PRISM Physiographic mapping of climate over US — orographic methods
mass_etal2002 Orographic precip processes PNW (Mon Wea Rev / J Hydromet)
williams_etal2020 Anthropogenic warming → North American megadrought (Science)
ficklin_novick2017 Globally rising VPD (J Climate)
grossiord_etal2020 Plant + ecosystem responses to rising VPD (New Phytol)
trenberth_etal2014 Global warming + drought changes (Nature Clim Chg)
marvel_etal2019 20th-century hydroclimate changes (Nature)
sheffield_wood2008 Global drought trends + variability (J Climate)

Existing items in climate collection to screen first

19 items already there. From #58 reuse pool, several are also
relevant on the precip/drying side:
munoz-sabater_etal2021ERA5Landstateoftheart (ERA5-Land soil-moisture
validation), dierauer_etal2020Climatechange (BC ecoregion drought),
islam_etal2019Quantifyingprojected (Fraser flow regime — was set
aside in #58 as Issue-2 scope), warkentin_etal2022Lowsummer (BC
summer flow + chinook), vincent_etal2018ChangesCanadas (Canada
precip trends are in the same paper as the temp trends used in #58).

Already in snow rag (cross-rag, no re-add):
knowles_etal2006SnowfallVersus (rain-vs-snow phase shift).

Phases (mirror #58 task_plan)

  1. Targeted lit search — candidate list, DOI confirmation, OA / RG access
  2. Add to NewGraphEnvironment/climate — PDFs first
  3. Build ragnar DuckDB at data/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdb
  4. Mine the store for methodology quotes (8 query topics)
  5. Synthesis + citation map in findings.md
  6. PR — squash, NEWS bullet, v0.x.y patch release

Out of scope

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions