Problem
Vignette interpretation paragraphs in vignettes/peace-fwcp.Rmd and
vignettes/kootenay-lake.Rmd make defensible-sounding claims about
precipitation departure and "drying" — falling annual precipitation,
rising VPD/evapotranspiration, declining soil moisture, "soils drying
due to both ↓P and ↑ET" (the v0.1.1 finding) — but currently land on
zero peer-reviewed citations. For FWCP fish-passage reporting
context, these need the same cited backing #53/#54 gave Snowpack
and #58/#60 gave Temperature.
Scope
Second of three sequential climate-departure lit reviews covering
the non-snow vignette sections (3-split: temperature [done #58],
precip+drying [this issue], interpretation framing).
Mirrors the #58 / #54 / v0.1.7 pattern verbatim:
- Targeted lit search → ~10 papers
- Add to
NewGraphEnvironment/climate Zotero collection (key
8MH9LCC9), PDFs first per /lit-search policy
- Build
data/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdb ragnar store
- Mine for methodology quotes; write
findings.md with "cite this
for that" map
- Vignette
[@key] insertion happens on a downstream branch, not here
Topics to cover
- Precipitation trend methodology — long-record analyses,
homogenization, treatment of trace events
- Heavy / extreme precipitation — intensity-frequency-duration,
anthropogenic attribution
- Orographic / mountain precipitation — rain-shadow gradients,
Selkirk-Purcell type contrasts (relevant for Kootenay vignette)
- Vapor pressure deficit (VPD) + relative humidity — atmospheric
evaporative demand driver
- Soil moisture as integrative drought signal — supply-demand
balance, temperature acceleration of drying
- ERA5-Land precip / soil-moisture validation — bias structure
(parallel to the snow-rag's Kouki 2023 for SWE)
- Drought-fish linkage — how summer-flow / soil-moisture deficit
propagates to thermal habitat for salmonids
Starting candidate list (will refine)
| Citation key (proposed) |
Topic / Why |
donat_etal2013 HadEX2 |
Global temp + precip extremes dataset (J Geophys Res) |
min_etal2011 |
Anthropogenic contribution to extreme precipitation (Nature) |
mekis_vincent2011 |
Adjusted daily Canadian precipitation dataset (Atmos-Ocean) |
daly_etal2008 PRISM |
Physiographic mapping of climate over US — orographic methods |
mass_etal2002 |
Orographic precip processes PNW (Mon Wea Rev / J Hydromet) |
williams_etal2020 |
Anthropogenic warming → North American megadrought (Science) |
ficklin_novick2017 |
Globally rising VPD (J Climate) |
grossiord_etal2020 |
Plant + ecosystem responses to rising VPD (New Phytol) |
trenberth_etal2014 |
Global warming + drought changes (Nature Clim Chg) |
marvel_etal2019 |
20th-century hydroclimate changes (Nature) |
sheffield_wood2008 |
Global drought trends + variability (J Climate) |
Existing items in climate collection to screen first
19 items already there. From #58 reuse pool, several are also
relevant on the precip/drying side:
munoz-sabater_etal2021ERA5Landstateoftheart (ERA5-Land soil-moisture
validation), dierauer_etal2020Climatechange (BC ecoregion drought),
islam_etal2019Quantifyingprojected (Fraser flow regime — was set
aside in #58 as Issue-2 scope), warkentin_etal2022Lowsummer (BC
summer flow + chinook), vincent_etal2018ChangesCanadas (Canada
precip trends are in the same paper as the temp trends used in #58).
Already in snow rag (cross-rag, no re-add):
knowles_etal2006SnowfallVersus (rain-vs-snow phase shift).
Phases (mirror #58 task_plan)
- Targeted lit search — candidate list, DOI confirmation, OA / RG access
- Add to
NewGraphEnvironment/climate — PDFs first
- Build ragnar DuckDB at
data/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdb
- Mine the store for methodology quotes (8 query topics)
- Synthesis + citation map in
findings.md
- PR — squash, NEWS bullet, v0.x.y patch release
Out of scope
Problem
Vignette interpretation paragraphs in
vignettes/peace-fwcp.Rmdandvignettes/kootenay-lake.Rmdmake defensible-sounding claims aboutprecipitation departure and "drying" — falling annual precipitation,
rising VPD/evapotranspiration, declining soil moisture, "soils drying
due to both ↓P and ↑ET" (the v0.1.1 finding) — but currently land on
zero peer-reviewed citations. For FWCP fish-passage reporting
context, these need the same cited backing #53/#54 gave Snowpack
and #58/#60 gave Temperature.
Scope
Second of three sequential climate-departure lit reviews covering
the non-snow vignette sections (3-split: temperature [done #58],
precip+drying [this issue], interpretation framing).
Mirrors the #58 / #54 / v0.1.7 pattern verbatim:
NewGraphEnvironment/climateZotero collection (key8MH9LCC9), PDFs first per/lit-searchpolicydata/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdbragnar storefindings.mdwith "cite thisfor that" map
[@key]insertion happens on a downstream branch, not hereTopics to cover
homogenization, treatment of trace events
anthropogenic attribution
Selkirk-Purcell type contrasts (relevant for Kootenay vignette)
evaporative demand driver
balance, temperature acceleration of drying
(parallel to the snow-rag's Kouki 2023 for SWE)
propagates to thermal habitat for salmonids
Starting candidate list (will refine)
donat_etal2013HadEX2min_etal2011mekis_vincent2011daly_etal2008PRISMmass_etal2002williams_etal2020ficklin_novick2017grossiord_etal2020trenberth_etal2014marvel_etal2019sheffield_wood2008Existing items in
climatecollection to screen first19 items already there. From #58 reuse pool, several are also
relevant on the precip/drying side:
munoz-sabater_etal2021ERA5Landstateoftheart(ERA5-Land soil-moisturevalidation),
dierauer_etal2020Climatechange(BC ecoregion drought),islam_etal2019Quantifyingprojected(Fraser flow regime — was setaside in #58 as Issue-2 scope),
warkentin_etal2022Lowsummer(BCsummer flow + chinook),
vincent_etal2018ChangesCanadas(Canadaprecip trends are in the same paper as the temp trends used in #58).
Already in snow rag (cross-rag, no re-add):
knowles_etal2006SnowfallVersus(rain-vs-snow phase shift).Phases (mirror #58 task_plan)
NewGraphEnvironment/climate— PDFs firstdata/rag/precip_drying_methodology.duckdbfindings.mdOut of scope