Skip to content

Pharmacy results September 2026

Jip Claassens edited this page Sep 15, 2026 · 3 revisions

Pharmacy results — September 2026

Headline results from the deck doc/lambda_sweep5.pptx (Dekhuijzen & Hilferink, draft for discussion, September 2026). Method on Lambda sweep method. Every figure below has a LOGISTIC twin in the deck; unless stated, numbers are LINEAR.

Not comparable with earlier decks. Two method changes — landbody-complete networks and NUTS region exclusion — change which residents are counted, so baselines, frontiers and the ranked lists all shifted (deck p8, p63).

1. Today's network

Catchment = residents whose nearest pharmacy by road travel time is this one (a cell's catchment split evenly among the pharmacies in it). Per country (deck p3, doc/pharmacy_descriptives.csv):

country pharmacies residents resid./pharm. #empty p10 p50 p90 max
Austria 1 467 8.9 M 6 088 3 2 422 5 666 10 203 25 354
Belgium 4 860 11.5 M 2 373 11 961 2 137 4 053 10 019
Denmark 536 5.8 M 10 736 0 4 892 10 014 17 801 35 188
France 20 698 65.3 M 3 155 660 1 182 2 869 5 495 17 502
Italy 12 991 58.7 M 4 520 56 1 040 3 160 9 107 85 669
Lithuania 1 253 2.8 M 2 240 0 671 1 782 4 507 13 754
Netherlands 1 992 17.5 M 8 765 4 2 661 7 952 15 567 33 497
Norway 1 057 5.1 M 4 835 5 1 661 4 300 8 548 23 011
Poland 13 791 37.1 M 2 688 3 878 2 280 5 017 19 078
Portugal 2 801 10.3 M 3 680 16 1 262 2 941 6 497 19 709
Sweden 1 448 10.2 M 7 078 5 2 098 6 208 12 659 37 107

#empty = pharmacies that are never the road-nearest for any populated cell. The same table per 1 km² location (cells with ≥ 1 pharmacy) and for the FR/IT/SE NUTS-1 regions: deck p4–6. The within-country spread is wide everywhere — the Netherlands alone runs from 4 394 (p10) to 34 905 (max) residents per location — which is why fixed min/max catchment caps were dropped.

2. The aggregated frontier — 41 areas, 43 320 pharmacy cells today

Aggregated frontier, LINEAR

Facilities and travel cost summed per λ over the 41 disjoint areas (exact by separability). Aggregate baseline travel: LIN 1 030 M person-minutes, LOG 30.3 M.

point w locations Δ locations multi vs relax Δ travel
LINEAR S1 same count 0.130 43 357 +0 % +0 % −26 %
S2 same travel 0.227 28 609 −34 % +3 % +0 %
fewest facilities swept 0.500 15 808 −64 % +13 % +55 %
most facilities swept 0.0001 433 828 +901 % +0 % −93 %
LOGISTIC S1 same count 0.00130 44 416 +3 % +0 % −13 %
S2 same travel 0.00282 26 673 −38 % +1 % −0 %
fewest facilities swept 0.0200 10 933 −75 % +11 % +65 %

Read: relocating today's pharmacies without adding any would cut population travel by about a quarter (linear); holding travel where it is, about a third of the locations are surplus. The Δ columns are native units and need no λ; λ only prices them (placeholder €100 000 per location).

Aggregated frontier, LOGISTIC

The same sweep read along λ

The sweep along λ: travel-cost bounds and facility count, all 41 areas

The frontier hides λ. Read along it instead — λ on a log axis, the two travel-cost bounds on the left (LP relaxation below, multistart integer solution above), the facility count on the right — and the sweep's dynamics show: the count collapses over two decades of λ (LINEAR: from ~433 000 below €100 per location to ~43 000 at S1) while the travel bounds stay on top of each other, and they separate only near S2. The dotted lines are the baseline, so S2 is where travel crosses its baseline and S1 where the count crosses its. The two count curves coincide by construction (n_open = round(Σy*)): the certified bound is on total cost, not on the count, so the informative gap is the one on the left axis. Under LOGISTIC the whole picture is compressed into λ ∈ [€10, €2 000] — the degeneracy of deck p64. Deck p65; the Netherlands version is p66:

The sweep along λ, Netherlands

Under LINEAR the Netherlands bounds open only above ~€50 000 per location, beyond S2, so its S1/S2 figures sit where lower and upper bound agree. Any area: python doc/lambda_axis_chart.py <REGION>.

3. Per country and per NUTS-1 — S1 and S2

Gains read off the multistart frontier by interpolation between adjacent sweep points; λ is the price per location at which the sweep reaches that point (deck p60–61, doc/frontier_metrics_interp3.csv).

country today # S1 · Δ travel (lin) S2 · Δ # (lin) S1 · Δ cost · Δ mean t (log) S2 · Δ # (log) λ S1 lin λ S2 lin
Netherlands 1 615 −12.1 M min · −19.9 % −443 · −27.4 % −8.0 % · −0.7 min −551 · −34.1 % 24 532 34 329
Luxembourg 86 −427 k min · −17.8 % −26 · −29.9 % −7.6 % · −0.7 min −30 · −35.1 % 15 945 25 641
Estonia 292 −1.3 M min · −22.6 % −94 · −32.3 % −13.4 % · −0.9 min −121 · −41.4 % 11 388 19 421
Latvia 496 −1.5 M min · −19.9 % −144 · −29.1 % −11.3 % · −0.8 min −183 · −36.8 % 8 822 14 262
Slovenia 306 −1.5 M min · −13.1 % −82 · −26.7 % −9.0 % · −0.8 min −99 · −32.4 % 17 680 25 450
Lithuania 582 −2.9 M min · −23.5 % −204 · −35.1 % −14.4 % · −1.0 min −268 · −46.0 % 10 987 19 834
Ireland 862 −4.0 M min · −16.9 % −235 · −27.2 % −8.8 % · −0.7 min −297 · −34.5 % 14 269 21 020
Norway 755 −10.3 M min · −25.3 % −326 · −43.2 % −18.0 % · −1.8 min −359 · −47.6 % 23 174 49 999
Denmark 466 −5.5 M min · −14.8 % −133 · −28.6 % −11.0 % · −0.9 min −166 · −35.6 % 37 082 55 960
Austria 1 129 −8.8 M min · −20.4 % −373 · −33.0 % −13.3 % · −1.0 min −497 · −44.0 % 18 361 31 027
Portugal 1 882 −7.4 M min · −21.6 % −527 · −28.0 % −8.3 % · −0.7 min −623 · −33.1 % 10 473 17 033
Czechia 1 624 −8.8 M min · −19.8 % −487 · −30.0 % −8.9 % · −0.7 min −587 · −36.1 % 14 550 22 885
Belgium 2 958 −3.2 M min · −14.9 % −520 · −17.6 % −3.0 % · −0.3 min −552 · −18.7 % 5 666 7 340
Poland 7 027 −23.7 M min · −17.8 % −1 883 · −26.8 % −7.5 % · −0.6 min −2 207 · −31.4 % 10 254 15 809

Selected NUTS-1 regions (all 28 in the deck):

region today # S1 · Δ travel (lin) S2 · Δ # (lin) λ S1 lin λ S2 lin
FR1 · Île-de-France 1 449 −2.9 M min · −23.0 % −218 · −15.1 % 11 918 16 444
FRI · Nouvelle-Aquitaine 1 584 −2.4 M min · −8.7 % −296 · −18.7 % 8 368 10 901
ITC · Nord-Ovest 2 890 −15.6 M min · −33.7 % −1 101 · −38.1 % 10 511 20 047
ITF · Sud 1 253 −40.7 M min · −45.8 % −732 · −58.5 % 30 189 101 789
ITG · Isole 891 −15.0 M min · −49.1 % −474 · −53.2 % 18 626 56 207
SE1 · Östra Sverige 388 −4.8 M min · −21.9 % −143 · −36.9 % 27 492 44 267
SE2 · Södra Sverige 452 −6.0 M min · −18.5 % −167 · −36.9 % 33 567 57 265
PL8 · Wschodni 1 065 −4.0 M min · −17.3 % −282 · −26.5 % 10 273 16 347

4. Which areas have the most to gain

Improvement potential relative to baseline, ranked, LINEAR

The improvement rectangle (baseline ↔ S1 ↔ S2) relative to baseline count × travel. Southern Italy stands far above the field — ITF 0.268, ITG 0.261 — followed by the other Italian regions (ITI 0.129, ITC 0.128, ITH 0.111), Norway (0.109), Lithuania, SE1 and Estonia; the French regions and Belgium close the list (FRI 0.016). Under LOGISTIC the top is the same (ITF 0.177, ITG 0.160, Norway 0.086, SE1 0.071).

Improvement potential relative to baseline, ranked, LOGISTIC

Bars are coloured by the pharmacy-regulation typology (formalisation level; T1 rule-of-law- anchored, T2 consensual-pluralist, T3 public-interest majoritarian). The gaps do not follow regulatory regime: the largest span both high-formalisation systems (Italy, Portugal, PL8) and low-formalisation ones (Sweden, Norway, the Netherlands) — geography dominates regime. The ranking is free of coverage artefacts: ITF ranks first on an unchanged value after the two scope rules.

Lambda at the balanced-improvement crossing, ranked, LINEAR

λ at the diagonal crossing — the price per location at which the balanced improvement is the optimum — ranks ITF (52 807), SE2 (45 168), ITG (35 671), SE1 (34 859) and Norway (32 176) highest, Belgium and FRI lowest. In € only through the placeholder; the crossing and the order do not depend on it.

Baselines and their frontier projections, LINEAR

5. How tight is the bound

The multistart upper bound sits +0–18 % above the LP lower bound under LINEAR and +0–4.7 % under LOGISTIC (deck p62). For most areas the two are now nearly a line; rounding costs most where stranding is dear, and the sparse Swedish regions keep the largest gaps (SE2: 56 clients stranded by rounding at S1 under LINEAR; SE3: 130 under LOGISTIC). ITF S2 is the one area with a +3 % gap.

6. A single area

Netherlands, LINEAR

Grey dashed = LP lower bound, blue = multistart upper bound, amber = log₁₀ λ (right axis); ★ today, ◆ S1, ■ S2. Netherlands LINEAR: 1 615 cells today, 3.48 min mean travel; S1 at 1 334 open (w = 0.300), S2 at 1 180 open (w = 0.341), both at +0 % over the bound.

Editor's note (15 Sep 2026). "S1 at 1 334 open" is the snapped sweep row nearest today's count (doc/deck_data.json, scen.S1, w = 0.3), the row the exported files and chart markers use — not the S1 of the table in §3, which is chord-interpolated at today's 1 615 cells (S1 bracket: w = 0.2 with 1 900 cells … w = 0.3 with 1 334). S2 at w = 0.34087 is a bisection point. Which artefact uses which definition: Scenarios S1 S2 S3.

ITF Sud, LINEAR

ITF, the area with the most to gain: the frontier lies far below the baseline star.

7. Open decisions and roadmap (deck p2, p63)

Decisions sought from the group: the travel-cost shape (linear vs logistic, and whether to rescale the logistic to match the linear at 0 and 60 min); widening the candidate radius before RSSV; territorial coverage constraints for equity, or keeping soft coverage.

Remaining, in priority order: communicate λ intuitively (person-minutes per location); widen the candidate radius per client (5 → 10 nearest existing), one area first; RSSV spatial-voting candidate reduction; an exact soft-coverage p-median MIP to pin S1/S2 at the baseline count; territorial coverage constraints; the logistic rescaling decision; calibrate the real fixed cost; capacity caps; counterfactuals.

Not pursued (decided 4 September 2026): the catchment-cap / min-threshold ladder; age-weighted demand; candidate cells plus their neighbours; urban/non-urban split and a settlement candidate set; flat-then-linear cost and logit-parameter sensitivity; pharmacist-based and pooled caps.

Clone this wiki locally