Skip to content

# Spec authoring task - #243

Merged
ProtocolWarden merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
spec-author/966912a5
Jun 6, 2026
Merged

# Spec authoring task#243
ProtocolWarden merged 3 commits into
mainfrom
spec-author/966912a5

Conversation

@ProtocolWarden

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner

Auto-generated by Operations Center execution.

Goal

Spec authoring task

Write a focused improvement-campaign spec at docs/specs/queue-drain-20260606T223739.md in this repository (OperationsCenter). The spec drives a multi-task Plane campaign; keep its goals concrete and bounded.

Required output

Create exactly one file: docs/specs/queue-drain-20260606T223739.md. Do not modify any other file.

The first line of the file MUST be an HTML comment recording provenance:
<!-- generated_by_run: baa74678-816c-46dd-9be0-6e2167e60c90 -->

Then a YAML front-matter block in this exact format:

---
campaign_id: <UUID v4 you generate>
slug: queue-drain-20260606T223739
phases:
  - implement
  - test
  - improve
repos:
  - <one repo from the Available Repos list below>
area_keywords:
  - <directory prefix or topic keyword>
status: active
created_at: <ISO 8601 UTC timestamp>
---

Then markdown sections:

  • ## Overview (2-3 sentences)
  • ## Goals (numbered list of 2-4 concrete, bounded tasks; each completable in one executor run under 1 hour)
  • ## Constraints (approach decisions, allowed paths, things to avoid)
  • ## Success Criteria (how to know it is done)

Available Repos

  • ContextLifecycle
  • CoreRunner
  • CritiqueExecutor
  • Custodian
  • CxRP
  • DAGExecutor
  • OperationsCenter
  • OperatorConsole
  • PlatformDeployment
  • PlatformManifest
  • ProtocolWarden
  • RepoGraph
  • RxP
  • SourceRegistry
  • SwitchBoard
  • SyncMechanism
  • TeamExecutor
  • VideoFoundry
  • Warehouse

Operator Direction

''

Recent Git Activity (OperationsCenter)

66fba66e fix(ci): green main — register reconcile_enforce key + drop unused import (#242)
f92223a1 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#241)
dba83e2d fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#240)
9bf3adf1 docs: clarify watch-all (OC pipeline) vs external tools/loop controller (#239)
cdf97c27 feat(reconcile): reconcile OperationsCenter .console (prune + scrub + enforce) (#238)
e06d5b5d fix(reviewer): reapply OC-venv ruff fallback lost in coverage merge (#236) (#237)
6225ed4c test: raise unit coverage to 95.75% and lift gate to 90% (#236)
70187b78 # Spec authoring task (#234)
9f9878cd test: raise unit coverage past the 85% gate (61.5% -> 86.9%) (#232)
568b5a38 fix(spec-author): strip executor run-ID comment before YAML front matter parse

Recent Git Activity (VideoFoundry)

87df0607a merge: reconcile .console housekeeping (6a40a0136) with desync fixes
674abab12 fix(vo): preserve real audio length in voice_over_duration (desync source fix)
6a40a0136 chore(console): reconcile .console/ — prune + doc backfill + enforce R1
07378d00e fix(scene-timing): floor overlay windows to actual WAV duration to eliminate early reveal
89563beef merge: bring pre-push hook chore (c50e33f71) onto dev
514195dc3 fix(audit): rebase overlay_drift gate on actual audio timeline to close plan-vs-plan blind spot
c50e33f71 chore(hooks): drop literal instance candidate from pre-push artifact discovery
5c4d3a2f6 fix(audit): treat zero-exit empty ASR artifact as observability gap
3cf546593 fix(echogarden,audit): fix large-v3 model download and treat ASR infra failure as None
6c169f589 fix(text-render): use tighter step for tied clusters to cap reveal-chain drift

Recent Git Activity (OperatorConsole)

eb5ee25 fix(ci): resolve E701 lint findings in watcher_status_pane (#66)
eb01e6c refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#65)
6ed719f fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#64)
8d4a732 chore(console): reconcile .console/ — prune completed history + enforce R1/R2 (#63)
4336d9a feat(hot-trim): trim log + historical backlog sections from the compiled context (spec §5) (#62)
b266fb7 fix(status-pane): put full section content in the scroll buffer
bcbba43 feat(status-pane): per-model worker backend rows; split Backend Limits section
80a1664 fix(pane): move controller idle countdown out of Active section
1d9dcd8 feat(pane): show controller idle countdown in Active section
9374346 fix(status-pane): exclude connectivity errors from recent task events

Recent Git Activity (SwitchBoard)

62e8af4 fix(ci): make CI green on main — lockfile, SPDX headers, doctor key, lint (#20)
a5786b3 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#19)
20bea20 fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#18)
097eccd chore(reconcile): enable R1/R2 enforcement (clean + under budget) (#17)
8662091 chore: remove stale kodo and archon references
c009ac8 Merge pull request #16 from ProtocolWarden/fix/fence-console-context
6970938 fix: add closing fence to console-context block in CLAUDE.md
f2e71d5 rename: ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner (reference update)
ecc8a52 chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in README
4fe3a6f merge: p5 LaneDecision.metadata + worker_backend emission

Recent Git Activity (PlatformDeployment)

cd70cba fix(ci): make CI green — add missing SPDX header + satisfy custodian-doctor (#30)
20d7760 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role resolution (#29)
739dbcb fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#28)
525f559 chore(console): reconcile — scrub private identifiers + enable reconcile_enforce (#27)
42e8ca8 docs(adr): ADR 0005 — sync-spec declarations belong in manifests (#26)
068e664 fix: land genericized sync docs + standardize pre-push hook (#25)
cfca45f docs: ADR 0004 + sync-topology — manifest as sync authority (#23)
d43f6a4 Merge pull request #22 from ProtocolWarden/docs/adr-0003-boundary-tenancy
8f945ca docs(adr): 0003 — single-tenant boundary artifact, multi-tenant migration
1766e0b chore(custodian): exempt ADR 0002 cross-repo symbols from K1

Recent Git Activity (Custodian)

3e282db feat(audit): DC9 — docs/README.md index-coverage detector (#35)
de50472 feat(context): targeted warm-injection rollout — ci-conventions leaf doc (#34)
75d4fa0 ci: install ripgrep for the federated semantic gate (#33)
d26e1ef ci: install ripgrep for the federated semantic gate (#32)
b2c14b9 ci: call the gate by its real entrypoint name (#31)
b7112fd fix(ci): make CI and semantic-federation green on main (#30)
5dc2e01 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#29)
2988ded fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#28)
e9eaf70 fix(reconcile): make R1/R2 opt-in (audit.reconcile_enforce, default off) (#27)
ee626f1 feat(reconcile): R-class detectors + reconciliation pilot (.console reconciliation spec) (#26)

Recent Git Activity (CxRP)

82c6196 fix(ci): declare reconcile_enforce via plugin_audit_keys to satisfy custodian-doctor --strict (#20)
7e25e0f refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#19)
caadd88 fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#18)
b0547fd chore(console): scrub private identifiers + enable reconcile_enforce (#17)
716ef94 chore: standardize pre-push hook to auto-discovering variant (#16)
d0799ce chore: remove stale kodo and archon references
db661a0 Merge pull request #15 from ProtocolWarden/chore/corerunner-refs
374720f chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in integration doc
bdbbf89 Merge fix/remove-kodo-archon-refs: remove live kodo/archon references
1f07356 fix: remove live kodo/archon references from src and test fixtures

Recent Git Activity (TeamExecutor)

e3d9497 chore(custodian): fail closed without the boundary artifact (#9)
0685485 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#8)
8bdfaf0 ci(audit): real custodian audit; rename ruff/pytest workflow to ci (#7)
e679a60 chore(console): reconcile .console — enforce R1/R2 (clean, under budget) (#6)
eac98ee fix: pin custodian to SHA; add ruff/pytest validation; upgrade stop.sh to Gen 2
f092f90 feat(team-executor): hard cut over middle tier to standard
2c96057 feat(runtime): add backend-specific team tiers
4977dfb chore: clear custodian findings + add unit tests (#5)
62753a0 chore: standardize pre-push hook file (activation deferred until findings cleared) (#4)
1568838 feat(p5): revert local cognition scaffolding, replace with cl shim

Recent Git Activity (DAGExecutor)

92c7074 chore(custodian): fail closed without the boundary artifact (#8)
e178188 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#7)
5f4b964 fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#6)
8c6d01c chore(console): enforce R1/R2 reconciliation detectors (#5)
e809cee fix: pin custodian to SHA; add ruff/pytest validation; upgrade stop.sh to Gen 2
2eb326a chore(hooks): upgrade stop.sh to Gen 2 ContextGuard (CL_ANCHOR-based)
3f8d37b feat(agent): add backend-aware model effort selection
0592d4f chore: clear custodian findings + add unit tests (#4)
1d19b61 chore: standardize pre-push hook file (activation deferred until findings cleared) (#3)
6209c6d feat(p5): revert local cognition scaffolding, replace with cl shim

Recent Git Activity (CritiqueExecutor)

2cd4c0a refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#7)
baa8f29 fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#6)
e88d1af chore(console): enforce R1/R2 — repo reconciled + clean (#5)
12ac488 fix: pin custodian to SHA; add ruff/pytest validation; upgrade stop.sh to Gen 2
210b15e chore(hooks): upgrade stop.sh to Gen 2 ContextGuard (CL_ANCHOR-based)
8a0a76b docs: clarify critique draft agent terminology
44d6448 feat(runtime): add backend-aware critique tiers
9fc7914 chore: clear custodian findings + add unit tests (#4)
34edada chore: standardize pre-push hook file (activation deferred until findings cleared) (#3)
a4e6d73 feat(p5): revert local cognition scaffolding, replace with cl shim

Recent Git Activity (RxP)

ea39c34 fix(ci): run pytest inside .venv to satisfy conftest venv guard (#14)
976d4c9 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#13)
3bb537d fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#12)
69bd01e chore(console): enable R1/R2 reconciliation enforcement (#11)
800f409 chore: standardize pre-push hook to auto-discovering variant (#10)
9ef1419 chore: remove stale kodo and archon references
75df1ee Add closing  fence to CLAUDE.md (#9)
c94e53c chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in GitHub templates
c41f95c Merge pull request #8 from ProtocolWarden/chore/corerunner-refs
819691d chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in all docs

Recent Git Activity (CoreRunner)

52a2f61 fix(ci): run pytest inside project .venv so the test job goes green (#19)
984a725 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#18)
fbb4f53 fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret (unbreak audit + enable R2) (#17)
19020fc chore(console): enable R1/R2 enforcement — repo reconciled + clean (#16)
f1438f2 chore: standardize pre-push hook to auto-discovering variant (#15)
d250870 Add closing  fence to CLAUDE.md (#14)
fa5ab8c fix: skip SIGTERM handler registration when called from non-main thread
a145a76 rename: ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner (reference update)
83a46cd chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in issue templates
111a867 chore: hard cutover — remove all remaining ExecutorRuntime references

Recent Git Activity (SourceRegistry)

e5ce32e fix(ci): run pytest inside .venv to satisfy conftest venv guard (#13)
1649442 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#12)
1abff0d fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#11)
8262f65 chore(console): enforce-only reconciliation — flip reconcile_enforce true (#10)
f049361 chore: standardize pre-push hook to auto-discovering variant (#9)
cca6508 Add closing  fence to CLAUDE.md (#8)
5e35d01 chore: rename ExecutorRuntime → CoreRunner in docs and templates
4a31a19 Merge fix/remove-kodo-archon-refs: remove live kodo/archon references
32dbcea fix: remove live kodo/archon references from src and test fixtures
89fd3ed Merge fix/gitignore-console-policy into main

Recent Git Activity (RepoGraph)

e9d85c9 feat(registry): shared private-manifest role resolver + instance-ref generalization (#5)
73222f9 ci(audit): add custodian-audit workflow (R2-in-CI via B64 boundary artifact) (#4)
80ed89b chore(reconcile): scrub scrub-target leaks from .console/ + enable enforce (#3)
4159561 chore: clear custodian findings + onboard hooks (#2)
687e604 feat(authz): can_anchor_host accepts canonical name or snake_case key
5a91cc5 feat(p2): manifest registry + can_anchor_host + find_anchor_for_path
aec0ac7 Merge pull request #1 from ProtocolWarden/fix/fence-console-context
e3d7752 fix: add closing fence to console-context block in CLAUDE.md
e9a476c Merge fix/gitignore-console-policy into main
fde9938 fix(gitignore): add CLAUDE.md and .custodian/tmp*.yaml

Recent Git Activity (Warehouse)

b00d7a5 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#8)
4fcdfae fix(ci): boundary artifact from B64 secret + hooksPath (unbreak audit, enable R2) (#7)
4bed4d2 chore(console): reconcile — scrub private-repo identifier + enable reconcile_enforce (#6)
999279f chore: standardize pre-push hook to auto-discovering variant (#5)
9cf6d4e Merge chore/track-console-files into main
855aada chore: track .console session source files
102a525 Merge fix/gitignore-console-policy into main
fb7694e fix(gitignore): correct .console/* pattern and add CLAUDE.md + custodian tmp exclusion
a0397cf Merge fix/license-headers into main
dfe3c89 fix: replace proprietary DV headers with AGPL-3.0-or-later ProtocolWarden headers

Recent Git Activity (ContextLifecycle)

4cc7b45 fix(session): retention audit follow-ups — recovery window, race, tests (#25)
811f526 feat(session): opportunistic two-stage auto-GC at session start (#24)
f077120 feat(session): cl session prune — age-based ephemeral-state retention (#23)
f0862af fix(reconcile): prune apply lock + index --check freshness gate (#22)
a194c39 feat(reconcile): treat the private-manifest repo itself as private (#21)
8a5fa06 feat(reconcile): private-repo scrub exemption — self-name signals private (#20)
f9d5a86 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#19)
2812e22 ci(audit): add custodian-audit workflow + genericize a docstring example (#18)
d028a85 fix(reconcile): one CHANGELOG line per item in prune (not per matched section) (#17)
034f26a feat(reconcile): index lists enforce-only public repos (full fleet view) (#16)

Recent Git Activity (SyncMechanism)

37ca59e fix(ci): green the CI workflow — venv test job + missing SPDX headers (#5)
862bb5d refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#4)
d1a525e ci(audit): add custodian-audit workflow (R2-in-CI via B64 boundary artifact) (#3)
f3f3423 chore(console): enforce R1/R2 reconciliation detectors (#2)
f35bab6 ci: add GitHub Actions CI workflow (lint, test, license headers)
1625922 feat(spec): manifest-declared sync-spec contract + CLI (#1)
563e5c2 feat: initial public-safe Syncthing install/runtime mechanism

Recent Git Activity (PlatformManifest)

88af9391f chore(console): queue one-time provision run for the other host (#73)
421c51061 chore(provision): pull CL/RepoGraph on re-provision (tool freshness) (#72)
9acfebb80 docs(anchoring): session retention driver — auto-GC at session start (#71)
b0ca0fcdb docs: close the three audit tail items (lease retention, §4 deferral, counts) (#70)
bd65452a7 chore: dashboard freshness gate in pre-push + shared private-manifest resolver (#69)
07a8449ff docs: fix 5 confirmed findings from the 4-arc spec audit (#68)
b39a63ff6 docs(anchoring): add OC executor-backend cl_wrap subsection (#67)
047956a8b fix(docs): index cognition-memory-overview from docs/README.md (DC7) (#66)
88575f975 docs(architecture): cognition & memory overview — the connecting document (#65)
51b8f4c7e docs(context): close phase-3 capture as superseded; retire inert stop-hook nudge (#64)

Recent Git Activity (ProtocolWarden)

cb17757 refactor: generalize private-manifest instance refs to role phrasing (#7)
5340fed ci(audit): add custodian-audit workflow (R2-in-CI via B64 boundary artifact) (#6)
2809d67 chore(console): enforce R1/R2 — repo reconciled, clean, under budget (#5)
6fe5c15 docs: add SyncMechanism to the org profile catalog; note CL tiered memory (#4)
5586d6d chore: onboard Custodian (config, hooks, README sections, changelog) (#3)
367bac8 chore: rename ContextLifecycleProtocol → ContextLifecycle
fb6bf2d Merge pull request #2 from ProtocolWarden/fix/fence-console-context
db7614b fix: add closing fence to console-context block in CLAUDE.md
2ac9f23 Merge pull request #1 from ProtocolWarden/feat/add-clp
d50e59d feat: add ContextLifecycleProtocol to org profile

Existing Specs (do not duplicate)

  • adaptive-loop-integration-tests
  • admin-api-test-coverage
  • ci-coordinator-decision-tests
  • cxrp-backend-card-vocabulary
  • decision-rules-test-coverage
  • executor-adapter-unit-tests
  • operational-health-test-coverage
  • p5-adapter-and-board-unblock-tests
  • platform-cli-test-coverage
  • proposer-consumes-custodian-sweep
  • queue-drain-20260528T093334
  • queue-drain-20260529T071544
  • queue-drain-20260529T072958
  • queue-drain-20260529T221550
  • queue-drain-20260530T070849
  • queue-drain-20260530T110727
  • queue-drain-20260602T154025
  • queue-drain-20260602T161637
  • queue-drain-20260602T162243
  • queue-drain-20260602T162852
  • queue-drain-20260602T172812
  • queue-drain-20260602T173420
  • queue-drain-20260602T234758
  • recovery-subsystem-test-coverage
  • reviewer-pr-state-machine
  • scene-timing-audit-test-hardening
  • watcher-entrypoint-test-coverage

Board Summary

  • ready: 0
  • running: 0
  • drained: True
  • trigger_source: queue_drain

Boundaries

  • Touch exactly one file: docs/specs/queue-drain-20260606T223739.md.
  • Do not modify any other repo content.
  • Pick exactly one repo for the repos: field from Available Repos.
  • Prefer 2-4 small goals over one large one.

@ProtocolWarden

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Needs human attention (reason=no_verdict_unreviewable). Left open — not merged (unresolved) and not closed (work preserved).

Self-review produced no parseable verdict after repeated passes (likely a transient backend/rate-limit issue, or a diff too large to review). The PR is left open for human attention; automated review will retry.

@ProtocolWarden

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Self-review concerns — auto-fixing (up to 6 attempts; re-queued if still unresolved):

Stage 1 — Goals completeness: Goal 3 contains an ambiguity that conflicts with the measurable success criteria.

Specific issue: Goal 3 states "Create 5–7 synthetic fixture repositories" but Success Criteria 2 explicitly requires validation against "7 fixture categories." This range creates uncertainty about the actual target number of fixtures needed to satisfy the success criteria.

Impact: The spec is not implementable without clarification — a developer cannot know whether to deliver 5, 6, or 7 fixtures without risking test coverage misalignment or over-delivery.

Fix (actionable): Change Goal 3 from "Create 5–7 synthetic fixture repositories" to "Create 7 synthetic fixture repositories with intentional policy violations..." This locks the target to exactly 7, matching the deterministic requirement in Success Criteria 2.

Other stages pass:
✅ Stage 0: YAML frontmatter and structure valid
✅ Stage 2: Constraints section valid and feasible
✅ Stage 3: Success criteria complete and measurable
✅ Stage 4: No tooling artifacts in diff
✅ Stage 5: Markdown formatting and clarity correct

To resolve: Edit the spec file and change Goal 3's range to a fixed count of 7 fixtures, then re-run review.

Operations Center Bot and others added 2 commits June 6, 2026 19:32
Goal 3 stated "Create 5–7 synthetic fixture repositories" (a range),
conflicting with Success Criteria 2's deterministic requirement of
"7 fixture categories". Changed Goal 3 to "Create 7 synthetic fixture
repositories" to remove ambiguity and ensure implementability.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Haiku 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
Documented the successful self-review and fix of queue-drain spec Goal 3
range ambiguity (5–7 → 7 fixtures) completed 2026-06-06.

Co-Authored-By: Claude Haiku 4.5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
@ProtocolWarden
ProtocolWarden merged commit 927b16a into main Jun 6, 2026
13 checks passed
@ProtocolWarden
ProtocolWarden deleted the spec-author/966912a5 branch June 6, 2026 23:55
@ProtocolWarden

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Owner Author

Stale-flag retraction (operator session, 2026-06-07 PR-history audit): the "Needs human attention" / self-review flag above was never retracted after conditions changed — this PR merged and main's CI failures of that period traced to the fleet-wide R1 detector-ID collision, fixed in #246 (main green since 2026-06-07T15:25Z). No action needed. A self-retracting-verdict improvement is queued in .console/task.md.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Labels

None yet

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

1 participant