test: v3 ACP-allowed proof - #147
Conversation
|
I now have everything I need. Let me write the review. PR #141 —
|
| Bucket | Files |
|---|---|
| docs | README.md |
Rust invariant checks
All pass vacuously — there are no Rust source changes in this PR.
- Determinism: N/A
- Workspace layering: N/A
unsafe: N/Aunwrap/expectin library crates: N/Aprintln!/eprintln!outsideplumb-cli: N/Atodo!/unimplemented!/dbg!: N/AHashMap/HashSetin output paths: N/Acargo-deny/ new deps: N/A
CI status
All 14 checks pass on the head commit (ca3d9c9b): preflight, test (3 platforms), determinism, size guard, MSRV, cargo-deny, Conventional Commits, docs build, coverage, GitGuardian, Claude review.
Findings
[BLOCKER] Net-zero diff closes issue #140 without satisfying it
The PR contains two commits that self-cancel:
e3265800(test: acknowledge v3 multi-agent setup in README) — adds<!-- aram-ai-global v3 multi-agent stack now drives PRs end-to-end. -->atREADME.md:1.ca3d9c9b(docs: remove hidden README metadata comment) — removes the same line.
gh api repos/aram-devdocs/plumb/pulls/141/files returns []. Merging this PR leaves README.md byte-identical to main. Issue #140 explicitly requests that the comment persist ("squash-merge once green"). This PR closes the issue without implementing what it asked.
[WARNING] PR body misrepresents the change
The summary section reads: "Added the requested top-of-file README comment acknowledging the aram-ai-global v3 multi-agent PR flow." This accurately describes commit 1 but ignores commit 2, which undoes it. The net effect — nothing — is not described anywhere in the body.
[WARNING] Wrong Conventional Commits type for commit 1
test: acknowledge v3 multi-agent setup in README uses the test: scope for a README.md edit. Per the Conventional Commits spec and this project's usage, test: is reserved for test-code changes. The correct type here is docs:. The CC hook accepted it (any scope with a colon passes the linter), but it is semantically wrong and will confuse git log readers.
Punch list
| # | Location | Severity | Note |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | README.md (net diff) |
BLOCKER | PR merges as a no-op; issue #140 asks for the comment to persist — either revert commit 2 and keep the comment, or update issue #140 to reflect a changed intent before merging |
| 2 | PR body, "Summary" section | WARNING | Inaccurate: describes only commit 1; revise to describe the actual net effect |
| 3 | Commit e3265800 message |
WARNING | Replace test: with docs: |
Verdict: REQUEST_CHANGES
Fixes #146
Summary
One-line CHANGELOG.md addition under Unreleased / Added — proof that the v3 visible-flow lands diffs end-to-end with acpx.permissionMode=approve-all + Codex sandbox=danger-full-access.
Test plan