Skip to content

v1.1.1 — Rule 3 'Keep units small' (cohesion over line count)

Latest

Choose a tag to compare

@cskwork cskwork released this 17 May 23:01
· 10 commits to main since this release

What's new

  • New Rule 3: Keep units small and cohesive — file/function size discipline promoted to a first-class commandment. Targets the failure mode where agents pile every concern into one giant file.
  • v1.1.0 rules #2 Surface uncertainty and #3 Offer options merged into one. Both addressed the same trigger (unclear requirements), so consolidation tightened the contract without losing intent.

Ten Commandments — behavior changes

  • #2 merged: "Surface uncertainty; offer options." If requirements are unclear, ask. If multiple valid interpretations, present 2–3 reasonable approaches and recommend the simplest sustainable one. If the request is risky, say so.
  • #3 new: "Keep units small and cohesive." One file = one purpose; one function = one job. Functions ≤50 lines, nesting ≤4. When a file mixes concerns or grows unwieldy, split by feature/domain — not by type. Cohesion beats line count.

Why no file-line cap?

Cross-checked Google (Java/Python/TS), PEP 8, Linux kernel, ESLint, and Pylint style guides — no major industry guide enforces a file-line cap. An earlier draft included "~200–400 lines per file"; dropped because the number had no industry consensus backing and risked cargo-cult splitting (290-line files passing the rule while still violating cohesion). Function-line (≤50) and nesting (≤4) thresholds remain because ESLint defaults + Linux kernel + Google Python guidance all align there.

Migration

  • Symlink users: git pull your clone; all linked CLIs (Claude Code, Codex, Gemini, OpenCode) auto-update.
  • Direct copy users: re-curl raw files from the new tag.

Compat

  • AGENTS.mdCLAUDE.md byte-identical.
  • Commandment count unchanged: 10.
  • No removed rules. Rules 2 and 3 from v1.1.0 are folded into the new #2.

Detailed reasoning

See log/changelog-2026-05-18.md for the full decision log, option comparison, and best-practice research.