/{collection url}/{taxonomy slug}/{term slug} view error 404

[wm-simon]

Bug Description

Route 1: /{taxonomy slug}/{term slug} view is loading
Route 2: /{collection url}/{taxonomy slug}/{term slug} view is not loading
Both routes should load the same view: {taxonomy}/show

How to Reproduce

{{ taxonomy:taxonomy collection="collection" }}
<a href="{{ url }}">{{ title }}</a>
{{ /taxonomy:taxonomy }}

Error 404 for the urls.

Extra Detail

{{ taxonomy:zielgruppen collection="kreise" }} <a href="{{ url }}">{{ title }}</a> {{ /taxonomy:zielgruppen }}

Environment

Statamic version: 3.0.0.-beta-28

PHP version: 7.4

Install method (choose one):

• Fresh install from statamic/statamic

[rosswintle]

I'm seeing this too.

Don't know that it's worth adding much detail. Let me know if you want some code from my case and I'll add it.

[rickmills]

Seeing the exact same issue on 3.0.0-beta.44 here. Not really a lot else to add detail wise, the only thing I've got with mine is a mount on the collection they relate to.

E.g

Page: 'Car Manufacturers'

Collection: Car Manufacturers mounted to the above page

Taxonomy: Car Models (car-models)

URL that works: /car-models/2020-edge

URL you'd expect to work but 404's: /car-manufacturers/ford/car-models/2020-edge

Oddly /car-manufacturers/car-models/2020-edge works but obviously cant be used as its not a uri that would make much sense.

[that0n3guy]

I'm also seeing this on 3.0.0

I have Blog collection and page (mounted).
"Tags" is the taxonomy.

The url /blog/tags works to the view ./blog/tags/index.antlers.html

404 url /blog/tags/planning ... but I have the view ./blog/tags/show.antlers.html

[that0n3guy]

I found a weird error on my blog page (the one the collection was mounted too). I deleted it and recreated it in the UI... then remounted... now my tag term pages work.

[rickmills]

I've given this all a try with a fresh copy of Statamic 3 just incase I'd screwed up my setup, and hit the same problem again.

I've re-read the docs, and I'm not sure if I missed it, or if they were updated but it now reads that the route I mentioned not making sense in my post above is actually what its supposed to be doing.

• This will work: /{collection}/{taxonomy}/{texonomy_entry_slug}
• Example: /car-manufacturers/car-models/2020-edge

But the route you'd want (example below) isn't ever going to work from the looks of things.

• /{collection}/{collection_entry_slug}/{taxonomy}/{taxonomy_entry_slug}
• Example: /car-manufacturers/ford/car-models/2020-edge

I wonder if @jackmcdade, @jasonvarga or someone with knowledge of the routing could confirm if this is the case, and if theres any plans to support taxonomy routes this way as at the moment mounting them and selecting the related ones within an entry isn't making much sense 😕

Edit: FWIW if you edit Routing/URIBuilder.php dumping out the $uri value in the build() method it's missing the collection slug. If you hard code it all the collection taxonomy pages work so deffo looks like a bug of some sort. Going to keep playing with it to see if I can figure out a fix.

[Grant-Smith-74]

I'm seeing this issue in 3.0.7, been chatting with Erin at support, but haven't got anywhere. I'll make Erin aware of this issue in case it's been missed?

https://statamic.com/forum/4838-filter-a-page-of-taxonomies-by-their-term

[jasonvarga]

These are the taxonomy routes we support out of the box: https://statamic.dev/taxonomies#routing
For the collection specific routes, make sure you have an entry mounted to the collection. That's what gives you the {collection url} part of the route.

It sounds like it works fine once you've mounted the page correctly.

There is another issue present where a multi-word taxonomy uses underscores in the url, but should be using dashes. That's over here: #2273

For the car manufacturers url example being discussed here, that's completely different and I'd consider it a feature request, not a bug. Please open an issue on https://github.com/statamic/ideas

[stuartcusackie]

This is still an issue for me on 5.50.0 - Blade tags:

This produces the correct urls but 404s when visiting:
@foreach(Statamic::tag('taxonomy:tags')->collection('blog')->sort('title:asc') as $term)

This works fine:
@foreach(Statamic::tag('taxonomy:tags')->sort('title:asc') as $term)

I have mounted my 'blog' collection to an entry in my 'pages' collection.

I have a feeling it used to work a few months ago. Maybe a recent release broke it again?