Workflow review batch

Workflow: review-batch

/agentic-sdlc:review-batch reviews several results in 1 pass. One blind reviewer scores all results, judges pairs and lists cross-issue findings. Two skeptics then check each major or critical finding. A finding stands only if both skeptics agree.

Args

Arg	Meaning
results	List of { id, diff, test }. diff is a ref range or a patch. test is the command that proves the result.
decisions	Text of the design decisions the results must follow.
rules	Optional. The code rules of the repo, as text.

The reviewer sees no author, no model name and no cost.

Phases

flowchart LR
  A[Review] --> B[Skeptics]
  B --> C[Result: scores, standing findings]

Loading

Phase	Agent	Model	Work
Review	reviewer (1)	Opus	Scores each result 1 to 5 on correctness, code rules, tests and scope. Lists findings by severity: minor, major, critical.
Skeptics	reviewer (2 per major or critical finding)	Sonnet	Each skeptic tries to refute the finding.

What stays outside

The workflow merges nothing and opens no PR. The PR, the CI gate and the merge to main stay with the main agent (see Agent chief-of-staff).