Skip to content

Propose removal of SOCKET_WEBRTC socket backend #27366

Description

@sbc100

I am proposing the removal of the experimental -sSOCKET_WEBRTC setting along with its vendored third-party dependencies (third_party/socket.io.js and third_party/wrtcp.js).

Background & Current Status:

• -sSOCKET_WEBRTC=1 was added to Emscripten in 2013 (commit 4fb9a41) as an alternative POSIX
sockets backend (libsockfs.js) to route connections over WebRTC data channels via an intermediate
signaling broker (WebSocketBroker).
• It relies on two vendored JavaScript libraries in third_party/:
• third_party/socket.io.js: Version 0.9.11 of socket.io-client from 2012.
• third_party/wrtcp.js: An experimental WebRTC P2P broker (wrtcp) written by Alan Kligman at
Mozilla in 2012–2013.
• The setting has long been marked in src/settings.js as: // Select socket backend, either webrtc
or websockets. XXX webrtc is not currently tested, may be broken.

Reasons for Removal:

  1. No Test Coverage or Maintenance: There are no tests in Emscripten's test suite (test/)
    exercising -sSOCKET_WEBRTC=1, wrtcp.js, or socket.io.js.
  2. Obsolete Third-Party Code: socket.io.js v0.9.11 uses the legacy v1 wire protocol. Upgrading
    socket.io.js to modern Socket.IO v4+ would require rewriting wrtcp.js from scratch due to breaking
    changes in Engine.IO and connection event signatures.
  3. Outdated WebRTC APIs & Hardcoded IP: wrtcp.js relies on deprecated callback-based WebRTC SDP
    methods, checks vendor-prefixed constructors (mozRTCPeerConnection, webkitRTCPeerConnection), and
    hardcodes a legacy STUN server IP address (stun:23.21.150.121).
  4. Better Alternatives Available: For non-blocking sockets, Emscripten actively supports standard
    WebSocket emulation (-sWEBSOCKET_URL), native proxying (-sPROXY_POSIX_SOCKETS=1), and direct
    node:net sockets (-sNODERAWSOCKETS=1).
  5. Codebase Cleanup: Deleting these two vendored files removes ~4,690 lines of unmaintained
    JavaScript from the repository.

Proposed Action:

• Move SOCKET_WEBRTC to LEGACY_SETTINGS (['SOCKET_WEBRTC', [0], 'No longer supported']) so -
sSOCKET_WEBRTC=0 continues to be accepted for backwards compatibility while -sSOCKET_WEBRTC=1
errors.
• Remove third_party/socket.io.js and third_party/wrtcp.js.
• Remove all #if SOCKET_WEBRTC branches from src/lib/libcore.js and src/lib/libsockfs.js.

If anyone is currently relying on SOCKET_WEBRTC in an active project or has concerns about its
removal, please comment below!

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    No fields configured for issues without a type.

    Projects

    No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions