Review of Guideline #48

Formatting

Item	Outcome
Guideline complies with the Guideline-Template	Yes
Name of guideline responsible with affiliation is clearly stated	Yes

Is the audience of the guideline correctly specified?

It is. The guideline is about partial reconfiguration choices and audience is defined as hardware engineers only. However, the configuration of the FPGA is also relevant to Application developers. It also specifies the limitation of the toolchain.

Is the expertise required to write the guideline correctly specified?

Yes

Are the keywords well selected?

Yes

Are parts of the guideline too generic or too specific?

The guideline is specific to a toolchain limitation for a particular hardware architecture.

Does the guideline explicitly refer to the handbook? To which part of the deliverable is it relevant (e.g., chapter of D1.2/D1.3)?

It should be referenced in the tool-chain chapter of D1.3 as a limitation of the Xilinx library for the moment to offer partial reconfiguration for Xilinx Zynq Ultrascale modules, and define the alternate hardware design.

Does the guideline specify the work done in the project that can benefit from the guideline?

yes

Other comments

6. References:

Track changes:

1. 23/10/2018: Guideline uploaded.
2. 30/11/2018: guideline reviewed.
3. 16/01/2019: guideline updated.