ZynaddSubFX pitch knob resetting on project load, export #3451
Comments
|
#2084 looks very related as Zyn and VST both use MIDI. OpulenZ, which also is MIDI-based is immune, though, and @tresf hints at it being fixed at some point before 1.1.3, see #2084 (comment). Not that I can see anything obvious in the git log... My primary guess would be that there is no pitch bend message being sent if the knob isn't touched, and pitch is being reset to some neutral state after export. #2204 is similar but not quite the same, SF2 player is not straight ahead MIDI like those others, so it might not be quite as relevant. |
|
Zyn seems to reload the entire plugin on sample rate change, which will happen before and after exporting IIRC. OpulenZ doesn't, it only kills and recreates the OPL2 emulator it uses and so it keeps all MIDI generated state it has. |
|
Since I still feel there's an underlying bug though... shouldn't |
|
... or is this a matter of Zyn overriding |
|
Nope. False alarm. |
|
AFAIK Zyn like all other midi based instruments does not support piano roll
pitch bends
…On 3 Apr 2017 03:57, "Tres Finocchiaro" ***@***.***> wrote:
I'm not sure if it's related but the export seems to ignore Zyn piano roll
pitch bends as well.
—
You are receiving this because you are subscribed to this thread.
Reply to this email directly, view it on GitHub
<#3451 (comment)>, or mute
the thread
<https://github.com/notifications/unsubscribe-auth/AF_bPQyZ3VByYDo9MGfR3pGc2XwQSukRks5rsFIbgaJpZM4MnMiM>
.
|
Those pitch settings are saved, loaded and ignored. Looks to me like
That As a bonus symptom, It looks like the pitch isn't properly communicated when loading a project, either. Probably because the plugin is created after the knobs already have been loaded from the XML. |
tresf
changed the title
|
Somehow this never got milestoned. It may not make 1.2.0 proper, but we'll try. ❤️ |
|
Project load pitch seems to be fixed simply by adding Project render isn't fixed by this patch. |
|
Found it. Just need to |
|
@Spekular I've fixed the symptom of:
I did NOT fix the symptom of:
... as I too could not reproduce. This may have been fixed somewhere along the way -- or worse -- could be a race condition in the code. We can open up a new bug report if the OP's issue resurfaces -- and ideally -- the OP would file the bug directly. |
Spekular
added a commit
to Spekular/lmms
that referenced
this issue
Jul 13, 2019
* Allow sub plugins for instruments aswell * Move m_key member of Effect into Plugin * Pass key to Instrument ctors and instantiaters * Add pluginKeys to all plugin selector widgets, and let them pass the keys when instantiating the instruments; or, if the keys must be passed over threads, pass the keys to the Engine using `Engine::setDndPluginKey()` * As instrument plugin libraries now also need to get their key passed, their second argument, which was always the same as the first, is now used to pass the sub plugin keys. This affects *all* instrument plugins. * Plugin.h: Add more virtuals to `SubPluginFeatures` in order to draw logos and images into instrument selector widgets * LadspaSubPluginFeatures: Implement the `displayName` virtual because the new behaviour to resolve displayNames is to first look at the SubPluginFeatures, which, without override, returns the superior plugin's name (Plugin.cpp) Additional: * PluginFactory.h: Allow setting up search paths without discovering plugins yet * Plugin.h: Add full documentation (should be checked) * Fix Engine.cpp not compiling on some compilers * Fix or remove wrong or useless debug printfs * Fix missing IntrumentTrack header * Use QString for SubPluginFeatures' virtuals The former virtuals returned `const char*`, which lead to invalid reads when `LadspaSubPluginFeatures` returned pointers to temporary `QByteArray::data`. * Test deployment preparation in regular builds (LMMS#4847) Tests whether contributions break packaging inadvertently * Add needed macOS shortcuts (LMMS#4851) Fix insert bars, delete bars, delete notes on Apple keyboard * Move apt_mingw_cache out of build directory (LMMS#4842) * Add missing include Compilation fails with debug build. Fixes regression from dd99f3a * Fix DrumSynth sscanf (LMMS#4869) * Fix failing build due to missing include Fix the build of MixHelpers.cpp which fails due to a missing include of cstdio (printf is not defined). * Add /sbin to AppImage search path Closes LMMS#4846 * Fix AudioFileProcessor tooltip (LMMS#4868) * Disable soundio on macOS Temporarily disable soundio on macOS to address stability issues with PortAudio Closes LMMS#4864 * Blacklist $HOME as VST directory Closes LMMS#4854 * Sync Debian version (LMMS#4840) * Sync Debian version * Drop temporary logging * Install 32-bit RemoteVstPlugin to a separate directory (LMMS#4797) * Fix loading 32bit VSTs on Linux Fix a regression in LMMS#4797 * Fix loading 32bit VSTs when loading LMMS in the build directory Fix another regression in LMMS#4797 * Fix MidiJack crash on exit * Fix uninitialized m_jackClient being used in MidiJack destructor * Fix destruction order in Mixer.cpp so that MidiJack doesn't access the deleted AudioJack instance Fixes LMMS#4688 * Fix LMMS#3926: QCursor in AFP Fix a crash that occurred on the following steps: 1. Add an AFP track. 2. Open it, and move the waveform display to overlap the track label button. 3. Close the AFP window and open it again by clicking the track label. 4. Move the mouse pointer. The problem occurs because the code makes the implicit assumption that AudioFileProcessorWaveView::enterEvent (and hence QApplication::setOverrideCursor) is called before AudioFileProcessorWaveView::mouseMoveEvent. This is not the case when the waveform display is on top of the track label. In this case the AFP windows is opened with the mouse being immediately positioned over the wave form display. There is no enter event and move events are issues directly. This then leads to a crash in AudioFileProcessorWaveView::mouseMoveEvent when trying to determine the value for is_size_cursor because the override cursor is still null but is dereferenced directly without checking. Only adding a check would not solve the problem because in that case the cursor would not change to the hand cursor when being moved inside the waveform display. The solution is to remove all calls to the global methods setOverrideCursor and restoreOverrideCursor and to only set the cursor locally. This fix is based on a patch by gi0e5b06 which is committed under 8a10c52 in his repository but for which he never created a pull request. * Fix CONTRIBUTORS override * Debian integration: update build dependencies It was wrongly done in 231a840. * Debian: don't bundle CALF LADSPA library separately anymore It's LMMS specific now * Better Wine detection and support * Support more Wine packagings * Allow building 64-bit RemoteVstPlugin using 32-bit Wine tools if possible * Provide suitable library paths for creating AppImages * Check if winegcc works before building RemoteVstPlugin * Modify VST build systems to make debian integration work correctly * Allow creating AppImages on systems newer than linuxdeployqt officially supports Note that the additional -unsupported-allow-new-glibc switch may result in an AppImage which is unusable on old systems. * Support FX Mixer for sample tracks and add controls to sample track window (LMMS#3866) This work is based on LMMS#3632 by @grejppi. * Fix zyn pitch on project load/export Closes LMMS#3451 * Add info about LadspaControls::m_noLink * Fix compilation on Qt4 * Avoid shallow clones in all Debian sid builds (LMMS#4888) hallow clone may break version detection. This is fatal in Debian builds, so use full clone. Note: This is safe for stable-1.2 but needs review after merging to master due to submodules. See LMMS#4888 for more information. * Add VST always-on-top config option * Ensure VST windows show properly in taskbar * Don't show error when loading empty VeSTige instance * Fix layout of VstSyncData struct Ensure member of type double is 8-byte aligned for consistent layout between 32- and 64-bit Linux builds. * Rework after code reading * Fix possible segfault in `SubPluginFeatures::displayName` * Minor fixes * Allow TabWidget to be variable sized * Allow instrument views to grow with contents Make InstrumentTrackWindow as large as the InstrumentView requires * Make instrument window's piano optional * Make Model class visitable * Forbid copying the Knob class * Always instantiate at least a dummy plugin * Fix too small instrument tabs Previously, they had been resized by the fixed size parent tab widget. We need to do this manually now. * Fix Blackman-Harris window formula (LMMS#4895) Adds missing parentheses * Automation Editor: Don't accept drag events when there's no pattern Fixes LMMS#4857 * TCO drag: Fix Ctrl+Drag crash Fix some assumptions that source and target of a drag actions are the same track container. Instead of looking up necessary information (track name, type and container id) by track index, add it to the metadata. Refactor canPasteSelection to take QDropEvent instead of the drop event's QMimeData. Coincidentally, this fixes the method to be consistent with its documentation. Fixes LMMS#4844 * Bump zyn submodule Per LMMS#4642 * Allow new Zyn bank creation on Linux (LMMS#4905) Allow new Zyn bank creation on Linux Closes LMMS#4642 * Fix empty editors after closing them and creating a new project (LMMS#4891) * Remove useless include * Fix invalid display names * Travis: use carla instead of carla-git Due to some breaking changes in the development branch of Carla, we can't use the package right now. Fortunately, the carla package now points to 2.0 series. So we will use it. See also: https://kx.studio/News/?action=view&url=changes-in-kxstudio-repos-regarding-carla-and-jack2 * Travis: fix shellcheck warnings for the Debian sid script * Remove some Qt4 compatibility code * SetupDialog: fix file dialog not opening for theme directory It was caused by a typo affecting a signal-slot connection. * Fix instrument window tab sizes - Fix the instrument window tabs minimum width and height formulae - Also set minimum height and width for instrument tab * PluginBrowser: Tree layout and search bar * [Equalizer] Bright analyzer colors, opacity increased (LMMS#4772) * [Equalizer] Bright analyzer colors, opacity incr Brightened spectrum analyzer colors and increased opacity a tad to make more visible * Fixed RGB Value * Update EqControlsDialog.cpp * Fixed color change * Changed colors again * Fixed colors, now brighter and bluer * Ok, its actually bright now lol * Replace Monstro icons * Shrink ComboBox arrow section slightly This is being done for two reasons: 1. The new Monstro icons (and the icons for Microwave when it's finished) are too large. 2. All ComboBoxes (subjectively) look much nicer this way. * Don't try to connect to nonexistent controllers (LMMS#4939) Fixes crash on loading presets with controllers. * Allow sample track TCOs to resize smaller than one bar (LMMS#4933) Other changes: * Update TCO position more exact when a drag leaves a TCO and enters `TrackContentWidget` (required to detect that the cursor has really moved when leaving a TCO with length < 1 to the right) * Use exact length when samples are loaded, don't round it up * Reset size when reloading same file * Use local cursor for TrackContentObjectView (LMMS#4918) Fixes crash on cloning patterns on Qt >= 5.12. * Add PluginIssue class (LMMS#4901) * Move macro definition out of class * Fix -1 offset in plugin tab In the instrument plugin tab, there was an orange stripe for TripleOscillator. This was because internally, TabWidget moves up the widget by 1 (TabWidget.cpp, line 89). The size of the whole window is: ``` widget->height() + m_tabbarHeight - 1 ``` So this code adds an offset of "-1" to the necessary computations. * Fix bad identation in old code * Coding conventions * FileBrowser: Backup expanded directories and restore that state when the tree is reloaded. * Allow build for Wayland w/o X11Extras, if VST off @lukas-w reminds in 134dae8 comments that X11Extras help Linux users of VST effects LMMS#3786. Now LMMS builds and runs on Weston without X11 dependencies, though only if WANT_VST is off. * Document Effect::checkGate * Document graph widget * Update wiki submodule * Fix wiki submodule * Fix notes getting stuck under high CPU conditions (LMMS#4908) * Record chords (LMMS#4938) * Added check for chord to notes recorded from keyboard * Make more connections direct for automation (LMMS#4942) * Improve dcast * document `dcast` * make `dcast` not only cast exact, but also upwards * add `dcast` test * rename `dcast` -> `dynamicCast` * AutomatableModelTest: Improve tests Check whether returned pointers from the cast are equal to the original pointers, rather than just checking wether they are not `nullptr`. * Fix CI on windows * Code style + Extend for TempoSyncKnob * Travis: fix a debootstrap error from missing keyrings Uses 18.04's debian-archive-keyring to fix the missing keyrings. * Don't draw note detuning info over the volume/panning area (LMMS#4965) * Show/Focus BBEditor on TrackLabelButton click LMMS#4946 (LMMS#4959) It will be shown even if the parent is hidden. * Use extracted linuxdeployqt directly As of probonopd/linuxdeployqt#370, the AppRun of linuxdeployqt unsets LD_LIBRARY_PATH. This behavior isn't suitable for our cases, so we use the extracted binary directly as a workaround. * Fix invisible note editing handles when a note has detuning info Fixes a regression in 32df2d7, the clipping area was restored in a wrong place. Also, a wrong value was used while restoring. * Fix the wrong merge * fix hanging mouse in piano roll (LMMS#4822) (LMMS#4960) * fix hanging mouse in piano roll (LMMS#4822) * fix hanging mouse in automation & pianoroll (LMMS#4822); * fix hanging mouse in automation & pianoroll (LMMS#4822) removed TODO comment that I forgot in the code * Fix race conditions in NotePlayHandleManager (LMMS#4966) NotePlayHandleManager::acquire uses a read lock unless the pool is empty. If two threads try to acquire NotePlayHandle simultaneously when the value of s_availableIndex is 1, one thread will try to read s_available[-1]. If the acquire action and the release action are done at the same time, NotePlayHandleManager::acquire may try to read data before NotePlayHandleManager::release actually writes. This commit prevents them by always using the write lock when acquiring a NotePlayHandle. * Nescaline and Freeboy - Better default sound (LMMS#4968) * Fix controller loading error on loading projects Fixes a regression in 91f9f1a, which added the range check into the wrong if statement. * Extend ProjectJournal docs, thx to @DomClark * Fixes LMMS#4781: Don't disconnect LADSPA automation on export * playing/recording pianoRoll's chord notes (LMMS#4963) * SampleTrack: call requestChangesInModel before unref SampleBuffer (LMMS#4982) To avoid a race condition between the gui thread which destroys the samplebuffer and the mixer thread which increases the buffer's ref- count, we'll make sure to touch the ref-count only when wh're synced with the mixer. * Making clearer the hierarchy. (LMMS#4967) Add `override` keyword * i18n: update translations from Transifex * Bugfix - SampleTrack -> Load & Save: Fix recorded sample track not being played correctly after saving and loading a project due to sample rate not getting saved in the project file. * Bugfix - SampleTrack -> Play: Fix sample track not being played in the right place when it not played from the begining. That has created a difference between the ticks and the metronome and the sample track. The cause of the problem was that the calculation of the frame to play was wrong: we had calculated `framesPerTick` according to the current engine's sample rate instead of the SampleBuffer's sample rate. * SampleBuffer -> Use processingSampleRate. SampleBuffer was using baseSampleRate as the default samplerate instead of the actual processingSampleRate. * i18n: update template strings * Travis: fix macOS build due to the old default version of Node.js appdmg recently dropped support for Node.js < 8.5 * MP3 export: initialize ID3 tag with id3tag_init Fixes wrongly set 'Blues' genre(ID 0) in exported mp3 files. * updated splash (LMMS#5002) * Fixes LMMS#4996: Fix metadata when exporting multiple tracks (LMMS#5005) Co-Authored-By: Hyunjin Song <tteu.ingog@gmail.com> * Fix German translation * Fix "Export Tracks" * Add "Export MIDI" [ci skip] * DMG rebranding (LMMS#5013) Rebrand macOS DMG background - Design and artwork courtesy @RebeccaDeField - Closes LMMS#4289 * fix color profile error (LMMS#5019) * Bump version to 1.2.0 * Add a save option to discard MIDI connections (LMMS#5021) * Song: add isSavingProject. * VersionedSaveDialog: Add support for a custom option dialog. * AutomatableModel: Support the discardMIDIConnections save option. * InstrumentTrack: Support the discardMIDIConnections save option. * SaveOptions: Show the save option dialog on "save as". * Enable dark title bar on macOS Closes LMMS#5031 * Travis: drop unneeded prefix setting for npm * Fix macOS builds * Increase Mixer fader falloff speed This also fixes a display bug that is present with large fader falloff speeds. * Replace tLimit() with qBound() and remove templates.h (LMMS#5040) * Replace tLimit() with qBound() * Remove templates.h * Add .editorconfig This file tells the github online editor to use tabs of width 4 instead of 8. Open [this](https://github.com/JohannesLorenz/github_test/blob/master/test.cpp) test file in your browser to see how it works (the width is 5 in the example). Actually, it also tells many other editors... * FadeButtons now remain partially lit as a note plays out (LMMS#4969) * MDI Subwindow Decoration for VeSTige instruments closes LMMS#2824 (LMMS#2826) * MDI Subwindow Decoration for VeSTige instruments closes LMMS#2824 * revert changes * change QMdiSubWindow to our SubWindow in Vestige * Drop sample on sampletracks (LMMS#5043) * implements drag and drop samples to sampletracks * clean up / take care of timeLineWidget heigth in songeditor * unused memeber removed * clean up * Update include/TrackContainerView.h Co-Authored-By: Spekular <Spekular@users.noreply.github.com> * Update src/gui/TrackContainerView.cpp Co-Authored-By: Spekular <Spekular@users.noreply.github.com> * Update src/gui/TrackContainerView.cpp Co-Authored-By: Spekular <Spekular@users.noreply.github.com> * Update src/gui/editors/SongEditor.cpp Co-Authored-By: Spekular <Spekular@users.noreply.github.com> * load AFP if we don't drop on a sample track * take care of timeLineWidget size changes * clean up * consolidate some code * requested changes by code review * move logic to SampleTrackView * clean up * clean up * clean up * Closes LMMS#5050: Add Mixer threading comments (LMMS#5069) [ci skip]
sdasda7777
pushed a commit
to sdasda7777/lmms
that referenced
this issue
Jun 28, 2022
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
Found by Exenon & reported on the Discord.
Steps to reproduce:
You should notice the exported track plays a lower pitched note. In LMMS, the Zyn instrument will now also play at a lower pitch as well.
According to Exenon's report, the pitch knob will visually reset to zero as well, and they have to drag it back up. For me, the pitch knob stays visually correct but has no effect. If I wiggle it a tad with scroll up and then down, it comes back into effect and Zyn will play at the correct higher pitch again.
This happens in 1.2.0-RC2. Exenon is on Windows 7 32 bit, I'm on Windows 10 64 bit.
Update: Creating an automation track that changes the pitch makes it work as well. This only has to happen once, for example:
The text was updated successfully, but these errors were encountered: