Repository navigation
Issue 375 REST API Wall Clock Times
GitHub #375, reported by @cloudcogsio Β· REST API, Change Management, Tickets Β· fixed in 5.5.0 (#2994)
An API client in Toronto (UTC-5) created a change for 20:46-22:10 on 16 November:
POST /api/v1/changes
{ "title": "...", "work_start_at": "2026-11-16T20:46:00-05:00", "work_end_at": "2026-11-16T22:10:00-05:00" }The change calendar put it on 17 November, 1:46 AM - 3:10 AM. Reading it back through the API looked right - "2026-11-17T01:46:00Z" is the same moment - so the client had no way to tell anything was wrong. A ticket's scheduled work did the same.
FreeITSM has two kinds of date and time, and the difference is the whole story (GH #116):
-
An instant - when something happened:
created_at,closed_at, a time entry. Stored in UTC, shown in each reader's own time zone, sent by the API with aZ. -
A wall-clock time - what a person typed into a form: a change's work, outage and PIR windows, a ticket's scheduled work, a task's schedule, a calendar event. Stored as typed and shown exactly as typed to everyone (
formatNaiveDateTime()in the UI), never converted.
The app treated the change and ticket schedules as wall-clock. The REST API treated the same columns as instants, in both directions:
// includes/services/changes.php and tickets.php - parseDate(), used for these fields
$dt = new DateTimeImmutable($v, new DateTimeZone('UTC'));
return $dt->setTimezone(new DateTimeZone('UTC'))->format('Y-m-d H:i:s'); // 20:46-05:00 -> 01:46 next day
// api/v1/resources/changes.php and tickets.php
'work_start_at' => apiIsoDate($r['work_start_datetime']), // adds a Zand the spec's own examples sent UTC ("2026-07-05T20:00:00Z"). Any client that followed them stored every time shifted by its UTC offset.
Was it more than one place? Ten fields over two resources, plus the filters: changes work_start_at, work_end_at, outage_start_at, outage_end_at, pir_actual_start_at, pir_actual_end_at; tickets work_start_at, work_end_at; and the changes work_start_from / work_start_to filters, which compared those columns with a UTC-converted value. Two other parts of the API already did it right: task scheduling (TasksService::parseNaiveDateTime()) and the calendar resource (apiParseNaiveDatetime()).
The trap inside the trap: TicketsService::parseDate() is also used for a time entry's entry_at, which really is an instant. Changing parseDate() would have broken time entries; the two schedule fields now call the wall-clock parser instead, and parseDate() stays for entry_at.
One parser for every wall-clock field, next to ServiceError so any service can use it:
// includes/service_context.php
function serviceWallClockDateTime($value, string $field): ?string
// accepts 2026-11-16T20:46:00, 2026-11-16 20:46, 2026-11-16 (midnight); drops fractions of a second;
// refuses a Z or an offset (422) rather than converting it-
ChangesService::parseDate()calls it (every date a change stores is wall-clock);TicketsServicecalls it forwork_start_at/work_end_at. - The API returns these fields with
apiWallClockDate():"2026-11-16T20:46:00", noZ. - The filters use
apiParseWallClock()(400 on an offset). -
spec.jsonand the OpenAPI schemas describe them as local wall-clock times, dropformat: date-time(which means an RFC 3339 instant, with an offset), and the examples lose theirZ.
Why refuse an offset instead of converting it to the server's zone? There is no single right zone to convert to - FreeITSM shows these times exactly as typed to analysts in any zone - and silently guessing is how this bug happened. A clear 422 tells the client what to send. It matches task scheduling and the calendar API, so the whole API now has one rule.
A client that sends these fields with a Z or an offset now gets 422:
'work_start_at' is a local wall-clock time and must not carry a time zone (no Z or offset): send it as YYYY-MM-DDTHH:MM:SS, exactly as it should show.
Those clients were already storing shifted times; send the local time the change should show instead. Reads now return these fields without a Z - parse them as local times. Every other date in the API (created_at and so on) is unchanged: UTC with a Z. The app's own forms already sent local times and behave exactly as before.
Records created through the API before 5.5.0 with a Z are still stored shifted; they are not changed by the upgrade, because nothing records which ones came from the API. Correct them in the app, or by sending the right local time.
| File | Change |
|---|---|
π£ includes/service_context.php
|
serviceWallClockDateTime() |
π£ includes/services/changes.php
|
parseDate() is wall-clock |
π£ includes/services/tickets.php
|
work_start_at / work_end_at use the wall-clock parser; entry_at unchanged |
π£ api/v1/lib/response.php
|
apiWallClockDate(), apiParseWallClock()
|
π£ api/v1/resources/changes.php, tickets.php
|
Output without a Z; the work filters |
βͺ api/v1/spec.json, api/v1/lib/openapi_schemas.php
|
Described; examples without Z
|
π’ tests/api-wallclock-times.php
|
26 checks, part 2 over real HTTP |
Reproduced first over real HTTP on a test install, with the issue's own values: POST /changes with 20:46:00-05:00 gave 201, stored 2026-11-17 01:46:00 and returned "2026-11-17T01:46:00Z"; a ticket PATCH did the same.
tests/api-wallclock-times.php: 26 passed. Part 1 checks the parser (local forms accepted, Z and offsets refused, an impossible date refused). Part 2, over HTTP: an offset is refused on POST and PATCH and nothing is stored; a local time is stored as sent and comes back without a Z, including the outage and PIR times; the filters compare local times and refuse a Z; a ticket's created_at still has its Z. Control: on the old code 10 fail, with the shifted values above. The existing change suites (approvals, risk policy, approver access, attachments) pass unchanged.
If you only use the app: nothing changes. If you have an integration that writes change or ticket schedules through the REST API: update it to send local times without a Z before upgrading to 5.5.0.
Not covered here, and not checked: CMDB properties of type date are returned as β¦T00:00:00Z, so a client that converts that to a western time zone may show the day before.
Related: REST API: Changes Β· Timezones and date formats Β· REST API: Calendar
FreeITSM β an open-source IT Service Management platform Β· github.com/edmozley/freeitsm Β· MIT licence
- Installation
- β° Scheduled tasks (cron jobs)
-
Architecture
- β³ π§Ή Root folder tidy (URL routing)
- β³ π Database Integrity (FKs & constraints)
- β³ π οΈ Database Verification β Developer Guide
- β³ π§© Service Layer (UI + API share code)
- β³ πͺ€ Code traps (the TRAP: comments)
- β³ π Commenting for the Engineering wiki
- β³ π οΈ Engineering wiki scanner - Developer Guide
- β³ π Service-Layer progress
- π€ Contributing (read before a pull request)
- π§ͺ Developer tests
- π PDF exports moved to PDFKit (#254)
- AI Providers
- Internationalisation (i18n)
- Timezones & Time Handling
- π Date & Time Formats
- π± Currencies
- π§ The sidebar (optional module rail)
- π§© Preference templates
- π Display order (modules, Watchtower cards) β Developer Guide
- Theming & Dark Mode
- ποΈ Recent β getting back to what you were doing
- β¨οΈ Command palette (βK)
- π Searching inside tickets
- π Attached documents
-
MobileβFriendly
- β³ π« Mobile: Tickets
- β³ π» Mobile: Assets
- β³ π Mobile: Calendar
- β³ π Mobile: Knowledge
- β³ π¦ Mobile: Service Status
- β³ πΌ Mobile: Watchtower
- β³ π§© Mobile: Problem Management
- β³ π Mobile: Change Management
- β³ πΏ Mobile: Software
- β³ β Mobile: Tasks
- β³ π Mobile: Forms
- β³ π Mobile: Contracts
- β³ π Mobile: Domains
- β³ π Mobile: People
- β³ π Mobile: Projects
- β³ ποΈ Mobile: Files
- β³ π Mobile: LMS
- β³ πΊοΈ Mobile: CMDB
- β³ πΊοΈ Mobile: Network Mapper
- β³ π§ Mobile: Process Mapper
- β³ βοΈ Mobile: Workflow
- β³ π₯οΈ Mobile: System
- β³ π Mobile: Reporting
- β³ π Mobile: System Wiki
- β³ π Mobile: Self-Service Portal
- β³ π§° Mobile: Techniques & Tricks
-
Security
- Layer 1 β which modules you can enter
- β³ π§© Module Access Control
- β³ π οΈ Module Access β Developer Guide
- β³ π Switching modules off
- β³ π οΈ Module availability β Developer Guide
- β³ π Module availability β design (#217)
- Layer 2 β what you can administer
- β³ π Roles & Permissions
- β³ π οΈ Roles β Developer Guide
- β³ π€ Why capabilities are constants
- Layer 3 β the System module
- β³ π Admin Access Control
- Hardening
- β³ π Security review response 2026-08
- β³ π‘οΈ Security hardening 2026-08
- β³ π οΈ Security hardening 2026-08 β Developer Guide
- β³ π‘οΈ Round three β plain English
- β³ π οΈ Round three β Developer Guide
- β³ π‘οΈ CSRF protection (S4) β Developer Guide
- Single Sign-On (SSO)
- ποΈ LDAP & Active Directory
-
π¦ Microsoft Entra ID
- β³ π₯ Importing people and groups
- β³ π» Intune: assets to their primary user
- β³ π’ Organisation chart
- β³ π οΈ Entra directory sync β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Entra import - review (#235)
- β³ π οΈ Entra follow-ups - review (#237-#240)
- β³ π οΈ Intune primary user - review (#236)
- β³ π οΈ Intune after an Entra import - review (#334)
- β³ π οΈ Intune primary user history - review (#338)
- β³ π οΈ Intune asset types - review (#339)
- β³ π οΈ Intune scheduled syncs - review (#344)
- β³ π οΈ Microsoft 365 in Integrations - review (#352)
- β³ π οΈ Organisation chart - reviews (#242, #265)
- π CardDAV contact sync
- Browser Extension
- API Reference
-
π REST API β how it works
- β³ π Proposal: custom fields, inventory import and change evidence (#194)
- β³ π οΈ Custom fields, evidence + inventory - review (#195-#197)
- β³ π οΈ Long forms in a task's Work view - review (#198)
- β³ π οΈ Empty Procedures fold - review (#247)
- β³ π« REST API: Tickets
- β³ π» REST API: Assets
- β³ π΄ REST API: Problems
- β³ π REST API: Changes
- β³ π REST API: Knowledge
- β³ β REST API: Tasks
- β³ ποΈ REST API: CMDB
- β³ π REST API: Contracts
- β³ ποΈ REST API: Calendar
- β³ πΏ REST API: Software
- β³ π REST API: Domains
- β³ π¦ REST API: Service Status
- β³ βοΈ REST API: Morning Checks
- β³ π REST API: Forms
- β³ βοΈ REST API: Workflow
- β³ π·οΈ REST API: Cost centres
- β³ π’ REST API: Companies
- β³ π REST API: Chart of accounts
- β³ π REST API: Projects
- β³ π‘οΈ API threat protection
- β³ π§βπΌ REST API: Analysts
- β³ πΊοΈ REST API: Network Mapper
- β³ π§ Using the API docs page
- β³ π OpenAPI specification
- β³ β OpenAPI: kept correct
- β³ π οΈ Maintaining the catalogue
- Watchtower
-
Tickets
- β³ Reply subject and replying to one message
- β³ π Live updates
- β³ π οΈ Watching a ticket - Developer Guide (1 of 2)
- β³ βοΈ Ticket address suggestions - Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ CSAT delay and reminder - Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Ticket checklist step types - Developer Guide (1 of 2)
- β³ π οΈ Right-click Attach checklist - Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Checklists in the REST API - Developer Guide
- β³ π A ticket's related block and attachments - Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Inbox.js map β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Floating windows & the file viewer β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Tickets settings β Developer Guide
- β³ π Simpler ticket and task forms - design (#218)
- β³ ποΈ The ticket workspace
- β³ π Forms on tickets
- β³ π The ticket table
- β³ π Rota copy and paste β Developer Deep Dive
- β³ β Checklists & SOPs
- β³ βοΈ Mandatory fields
- β³ π§Ύ Custom ticket fields
- β³ π·οΈ Ticket categories
- β³ π§Ύ A type for every new ticket
- β³ π₯ Assigning tickets to a team, and escalation
- β³ π’ One board across every company
- β³ π Many companies: searchable lists (#358)
- β³ π Ticket dashboard β Developer Guide
- β³ Mailbox Authentication
- β³ π€ Email send log
- β³ βοΈ Emailed reports
- β³ π Attachment size limits and large emails
-
β³ Basic IMAP mailboxes
- β³ π Basic IMAP without the PHP extension (#257)
- β³ π οΈ Basic IMAP client β Developer Guide
- β³ π§ͺ Basic IMAP client β Testing and verifying
- β³ π οΈ Basic IMAP - Sent copy - Developer Guide (#270)
- β³ π οΈ Verifying a mail folder β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Mailbox providers β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ How Gmail mail collection works β Developer Guide
- β³ Email rendering & images
- β³ SLA Management
- β³ WhatsApp channel
-
β³
βοΈ Telegram channel - β³ β CSAT company scope and filters β Developer Guide
- β³ π₯ Microsoft Teams channel
- β³ π¨οΈ Mattermost channel
- β³ π¬ Web chat channel
- β³ π£ Slack channel
- β³ π Linking tickets
- β³ β Record previews
- β³ π Ticket notes: internal or shared
- β³ ποΈ Canned responses
- β³ βοΈ Limiting replies to particular senders
- β³ π¨ Telling the analyst a ticket is theirs
- β³ βοΈ Email signatures
- β³ π The public web address
- β³ π’ Ticket numbering
- β³ π Raising a ticket for someone else
- β³ π Merging tickets
- β³ π Confidential tickets
- β³ π₯ Portal managers
- β³ π Who has seen a ticket
- β³ π Reading long tickets
- β³ β Splitting tickets
- β³ β Selecting several tickets
- β³ ποΈ The folder pane
- β³ π½ Just my tickets, or no closed ones
- β³ π οΈ Snoozing tickets β Developer Guide
- β³ π₯ Collision detection
- β³ β±οΈ Time tracking
- β³ π Case reports - a ticket and its work as one PDF
- β³ π Scheduled work in your own calendar
- Problem Management
-
Tasks
- β³ π οΈ Task board and subtasks β Developer Guide
- β³ π§βπ€βπ§ People on a task ("Involved")
- β³ π Repeating tasks
- β³ π’ Moving a task between companies
- π Projects
-
Assets
- β³ π οΈ Asset list by type - review (#340)
- β³ π’ Moving an asset between companies
- β³ π Shared asset locations
- β³ π§βπΌ Assigning assets to analysts
- β³ π Warranty and lease alerts
- β³ π Leases
- β³ π Saved table views
- β³ π¨οΈ Recording anything, and importing it
- β³ π§© Asset type layouts
- β³ π Inventory freshness
- β³ π Linked configuration item
- β³ π Connected assets
- β³ π Asset review
-
β³ π·οΈ QR asset labels
- β³ π οΈ QR asset labels β Developer Guide
- β³ π Asset label designer - design (#229)
- β³ π· Asset scanning β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Asset tag numbering β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Asset reconciliation β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Reconciliation, tags + labels - review (#164)
- β³ π Who holds what, and handover documents
- β³ π₯οΈ The inventory agent (PowerShell)
- β³ ποΈ Proxmox VE servers
- β³ βοΈ VMware Cloud Director servers
- β³ πͺ Hyper-V and Failover Clusters
- β³ π Linking equipment to tickets
- β³ βοΈ Follow-up tasks on a ticket
- Knowledge
- Change Management
- Calendar
- Morning Checks
- Reporting
- Software
-
Forms
- β³ π¨ The form designer β Developer Guide
- β³ π Layout & the grid β Developer Guide
- β³ ποΈ Collections β grouping submissions
- β³ π Submissions as PDFs
- β³ β‘ What happens next β a form's own actions
- β³ π οΈ Sections & conditional logic β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Lookup fields β Developer Guide
- β³ π‘οΈ Catalogue request approvals
- People
- Starters & leavers
- Domains
- ποΈ Files
- Contracts
- Service Status
- π Notifications
- π¨ War Room
- Self-Service Portal
- LMS
- Process Mapper
-
CMDB
- β³ π§± Designing your CMDB
- β³ π οΈ CMDB β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Impact analysis β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Data quality β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Record references β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ CMDB assistant - Developer Guide
- β³ π Linked assets
- β³ π Linking an asset to its CI - design (#201)
- β³ π Discovery and redundancy-aware impact - design (#199)
- β³ π οΈ Relationship wording - review (#297)
- Network Mapper
-
Workflows
- β³ π οΈ Workflow engine β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Workflows for tasks β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Workflow notes on a ticket β Developer Guide
- β³ π οΈ Workflow category routing β Developer Guide
- β³ π Workflows in order, child tickets - design (#304)
- β³ β° Time-Based Triggers
- β³ πͺ Webhooks
- β³ π¬ Webhook Message Formats
- β³ π HTTPS Certificates & CA Bundles
- β³ π οΈ SSL Verification β the Global Setting
- β³ π Workflow & Webhook Pitfalls
- Issue trackers (Jira, Azure DevOps)
- π‘ Zabbix (monitoring)
- π¬ Microsoft Teams alerts
- π 3CX (phone system)
-
System
- β³ π οΈ System cards by topic - review (#347)
- β³ π¦ Microsoft 365 (Entra ID and Intune)
- β³ π οΈ Preferences β Developer Guide
- β³ π§Ή Maintenance
- β³ βοΈ Emailed reports
- β³ π Finding people in the Analysts list
- β³ πͺ When an analyst leaves
- β³ π οΈ System β Branding β Developer Guide
- β³ π©Ί Page health (D019) β Developer Guide
- β³ β Feature Bingo
- β³ π Locations
- β³ π·οΈ Cost centres
- β³ π Chart of accounts
- β³ π· Photo Album
- β³ Demo Data
- β³ π οΈ Demo Data β Developer Guide
-
Overview
- β³ π Progress tracker
- β³ Concepts & vocabulary
- β³ Email routing & mailboxes
- β³ Settings: global vs per-company
- β³ Users & self-service
- β³ Staff cross-company access
- β³ One company supporting another
- β³ π’ One board across every company
- β³ Worked examples
- β³ Pitfalls & gotchas
- β³ Scope: what it's for
- β³ π οΈ Developer Guide (make a module multi-company)
- β³ ποΈ Case study: CMDB (a linked graph)
- β³ π§ͺ Test harness (prove it's isolated)
- What this is
-
π Bugs resolved
- β³ π #375 REST API wall-clock times
- β³ π #374 Calendar popup ran off the screen
- β³ π’ #373 All companies: Changes, CMDB, Starters
- β³ π’ #356 Assets People and All companies
- β³ π #366 LMS demo data would not import
- β³ π #362/#365 Team handover showed only a name
- β³ ποΈ #369 Inbox empty until Database Verification
- β³ πͺ #360 Links opened inside the ticket
- β³ π #354 Workspace Links missed tasks
- β³ π Task company checks in the API (5.5.0)
- β³ π Asset holders through the API (5.4.0)
- β³ π Files folder delete did not check inside (5.4.0)
- β³ π The Intune tab did not check the company
- β³ π #332 Files viewer would not open
- β³ π #333 Note attachments downloaded
- β³ πͺ #326/#327 Form webhook Full record
- β³ π #325 Form PDF download failed
- β³ π Small fixes in 5.1.0
- β³ π CMDB relationships read backwards (5.1.0)
- β³ π #301 CSAT delay was never applied
- β³ π #281 Comments imported from Jira never arrived
- β³ π #288 A change failed to open with Enforce approvals on
- β³ π Long non-Latin articles never got an embedding
- β³ π« #280 Email lookups scanned the whole table
- β³ β #266 Dragging a task told nobody
- β³ π #255 Article previews showed HTML codes
- β³ π #252 A link to a Knowledge article did not open
- β³ π #254 PDFs could not print Polish
- β³ π #250 Clicking a folder left the open article on screen
- β³ π« #260 The dashboard cog did nothing
- β³ π« #248 A department rule never matched on four routes
- β³ π A directory account could be matched to someone else
- β³ π« #244 Reply went to the assigned analyst
- β³ π Mailbox sign-in was not checked
- β³ π Four weaknesses around signing in
- β³ π A lookup answer could name any record
- β³ π« #227 A mailbox could not be deleted
- β³ π« #226 A picture on a note could not be closed
- β³ π» #222 The Assets page never loaded in 4.3.0
- β³ βοΈ #214 A "contains" condition did not match capitals
- β³ βοΈ #216 A workflow email from a chosen mailbox always failed
- β³ π³ The Docker image was missing PHP extensions
- β³ π A failed DNS lookup read as a missing record
- β³ π A link could change data
- β³ π Access outlived its removal
- β³ π Knowledge articles could run scripts
- β³ π Knowledge writes ignored permissions
- β³ π Company boundaries (Oct 2026)
- β³ π Smaller gaps (Oct 2026)
- β³ π Escaped text could leave its attribute
- β³ π Task descriptions were not cleaned
- β³ π Task documents ignored company scope
- β³ π Repeating tasks ignored company scope
- β³ π¬ #183 Mailbox checks overlapped
- β³ π #188 Transfer lock shown off when unknown
- β³ β #184 Subtask names and Overdue
- β³ π§© #186 Teams: the buttons did nothing
- β³ π Text in a change could run script
- β³ π AI settings changed without the AI permission
- β³ πͺ #178 Deleting an analyst failed
- β³ π« A team with no departments showed 0 tickets
- β³ π Projects: adding a phase did nothing on Save
- β³ π Leavers could still sign in
- β³ πΌοΈ Logo and courses broke on Apache with PHP-FPM
- β³ π’ Chat tickets ignored your ticket numbering
- β³ π Dates shown as a dash, or in server time
- β³ π Assets β Users showed people from other companies
- β³ π Restricted analysts could read other modules' data
- β³ πΌοΈ Replies with a picture in the thread failed to send
- β³ π Reply attachments never reached the customer
- β³ π οΈ Outbound email attachments β Developer Guide
- β³ π A global SSO provider was missing from the portal
- β³ π Behind a proxy, the SSO redirect said http
- β³ βοΈ The portal tagline moved when you saved it
- β³ π¨ The portal settings screen forgot what you saved
- β³ π‘οΈ The approvals inbox said "Error" and nothing else
- β³ π A table's answers were missing from the PDF
- β³ β A single-select column let you tick every option
- β³ π The portal ignored a form's field widths
- β³ π The tasks board stopped taking clicks
- β³ ποΈ #121 The index list is out of date after upgrading
- β³ π #133 The calendar subscription was empty
- β³ π #131 Tasks always reopened on the board
- β³ π₯ #129 Every page returned HTTP 500 after upgrading
- β³ π³ #127 A PHP warning above the System page
- β³ π #126 Notes stamped with the server's clock
- β³ π Storing every date in UTC
- β³ πͺ The portal was down for everyone signed in
- β³ βοΈ #120 Workflow notes could never be written
- β³ βοΈ #123 Three errors when running Database Verification
- β³ π #122 The description box was a stub in the corner
- β³ π£ Demo data deleted real accounts
- β³ π #117 Sign-in redirected to the wrong address
- β³ π¨ #108 The priority dot was invisible
- β³ β±οΈ #116 Time logged from the right-click menu
- β³ π #114 API keys refused by our own guard
- β³ ποΈ #110 Assigning a task told nobody
- β³ πͺ #107 Signed out while still working
- β³ π #103 "Share with Requester" reached nobody
- β³ π #102 Search found nothing for hyphens
- β³ πͺ #101 Source code editor opened behind
- β³ βοΈ #88 Subtasks could not be ticked off
- β³ π» #84 Asset deep link selected nothing
- β³ π« #79 A new ticket arrived with no status
- β³ π§ #79 A ticket from email did not say so
- β³ π #78 Bell opened to nothing
- β³ π¬ #77 Mail only collected from Inbox
- β³ π #74 The default password could not be changed
- β³ π¦ #70 Renaming an impact level
- β³ π€ #67 App-only mailboxes could not send
- β³ π #45 Verify only ever worked for Microsoft
- β³ π #45 IMAP reported as not authenticated
- β³ βοΈ An email template stopped escaping itself
- β³ π The portal dashboard showed the wrong time
- β³ π’ The folder said 99 and the list showed 96