Pending Owner Decisions

Pending Owner Decisions

Claude-owned (2026-06-02). The single place a code owner can see every open decision the deep-review campaign surfaced, each with its finding(s) and the affected subsystem. The Codebase coverage ledger is "green except Auth/PV cells"; those residual cells are exactly the decisions below — review work is complete, what remains is choosing and applying fixes. Severity uses the Deep-review findings tiers.

1. The big one — economy/forgery authority (one decision, whole class)

Decision: add server-side authority to spend/effect paths, or accept client-authoritative economy and ship a real BattlEye filter set. The forgery class has two surfaces and the decision must cover both:

• PVF dispatcher — Server/Client_HandlePVF.sqf Call Compile the sender's command string (DR-1). Fix: validate against the known SRVFNC*/CLTFNC* set + re-derive authority in each handler. (Same change removes a per-message recompile, DR-38.)
• Direct publicVariableServer channels — e.g. ATTACK_WAVE_INIT (DR-41); each needs its own server re-derivation. See Public variable channel index.

Path	Finding	Severity
PVF dispatch RCE/forgery	DR-1	High
Construction (RequestStructure/RequestDefense/MHQ)	DR-6	High
Unit purchase	DR-14	High (architectural)
Structure sale	DR-16	High
Side-supply transfer	DR-22	High
Upgrades	DR-23	High
ICBM superweapon (forged RequestSpecial)	DR-27	Critical
Gear/EASA + vehicle rearm/repair/refuel/heal	DR-28	High
Attack-wave price modifier (direct PV)	DR-41	High
BattlEye option is not shipped (22-byte kickAFK stub only, no scripts.txt)	DR-30	informs the choice

Caveat (DR-30): BattlEye filter files normally live in the server's BEpath outside the mission PBO, so confirm the production posture with the server owner before assuming it is unprotected.

2. Other correctness fixes (owner-scoped, source-cited)

Decision	Finding	Severity	Note
Victory winner-inversion + duplicate game-end	DR-11, DR-13 (mechanism DR-36)	High	one-line: parenthesize/guard both win clauses with !WFBE_GameOver + exitWith the side forEach on win
Threeway mode has no victory detection	DR-12	Medium	enable detection when WFBE_C_VICTORY_THREEWAY != 0
Commander-assign call-shape bug	DR-15	Medium	_side = _this → _this select 0
Supply-mission cooldown key casing	DR-18	Medium	align lastSupplyMissionRun vs LastSupplyMissionRun (case-sensitive getVariable)
HQ-killed non-idempotent score exploit	DR-20	Medium	idempotency guard on the killed-EH
Factory queue soft-lock + broadcast churn	DR-33	Medium	decrement WFBE_C_QUEUE on all exit paths; unique token
HC static-defence update-back commented out	DR-42	Low/Med	restore the update-back or document as fire-and-forget
DiscordBot TypeNameHandling.All insecure deser	DR-31	High (latent)	.All → .None (data is a flat DTO)
GLOBALGAMESTATS extension dormant deser + async-void race	DR-29	Med	delete dead .Auto load; fix File.Replace race

3. Keep-or-remove / maintenance-model decisions

Decision	Finding	Note
Modded missions: regenerate from source vs maintain as forks	DR-32	Napf/eden/lingor are divergent hand-edited forks; source fixes don't reach them
4 abandoned stub missions: complete or delete	DR-32	sahrani/dingor/tavi/isladuala are non-runnable (1–20 files)
MASH map-marker feature: revive or remove	DR-34	dead both ends; revive needs server-held list + JIP re-send
Paratrooper drop markers: revive or remove	DR-2	dead receive path
Dead WASP actions (OnArmor, GearYourUnit)	DR-35	commented in AddActions.sqf
supplyMissionActive.sqf dead twin	DR-39	compiled but never called
Duplicate Init_Server function binds (6)	DR-43b	de-duplicate; LogGameEnd dup relates to DR-13
version.sqf referenced by description.ext:39 but absent from source	DR-43a	commit a source version.sqf or document pack-time generation

4. Robustness / defense-in-depth (optional)

Decision	Finding	Note
Post-join wfbe_* waitUntil chain has no timeouts	DR-37	a never-set synced var hangs the JIP client; add defensive timeouts
Server-FPS hosted/listen busy-loop	DR-19	move sleep outside the isDedicated guard
WASP global_marking_monitor.sqf:62 sleepless display-wait	DR-40	use the throttled waitUntil {sleep …; cond} idiom

Continue Reading

Scoreboard: Codebase coverage ledger | Evidence: Deep-review findings | Channels: Public variable channel index